Sweet! A Look into The Origin of Sugars 

The revelation that ribonucleic acid (RNA) can act as a catalyst in many biologically important reactions revolutionized our understanding of life’s origins, placing RNA at the heart of the “RNA World” hypothesis (Higgs and Lehman 2015). Therefore, understanding the origin of the building blocks that make up RNA is a crucial step in uncovering how life emerged on Earth. While significant progress has been made in understanding how nucleobases and phosphates formed, the prebiotic origin of the sugar backbone remains a subject of debate (Omran 2023). 

In 1859, Alexander Butlerov discovered the formose reaction, demonstrating that heating formaldehyde under alkaline conditions yielded a mixture of sugars, which was verified through Butlerov’s own tasting of the solution (Omran et al. 2020). Because formaldehyde has been abundantly found in interstellar space and could have been delivered to Earth via meteorites, the formose reaction has long been considered the key pathway for prebiotic synthesis of essential sugars, such as ribose (Omran 2023). However, despite its geochemical plausibility, the reaction’s relevance to prebiotic chemistry faces doubts due to the inherent instability of sugar under alkaline conditions (Benner et al. 2012). Furthermore, the formose reaction, when reproduced in a lab at ambient temperatures, yields a mixture containing unwanted branched ketoses and tar formation. These drawbacks complicate the argument that the formose reaction alone provided the ribose needed for life on early Earth, with researchers proposing alternate pathways and environments for prebiotic sugar synthesis (Krishnamurthy and Liotta 2023). 

Supported by recent detections of extraterrestrial sugars in meteorites, another leading hypothesis proposes an exogenous origin, suggesting that prebiotic sugars were delivered to Earth. The first discovery of extraterrestrial ribose was reported by Furukawa et al. in 2019, where ribose, arabinose, xylose, and lyxose were identified in the Murchison meteorite. Subsequently, in 2026, analysis of samples from the asteroid Bennu also revealed many of these biologically relevant sugars . These discoveries raised an intriguing question regarding the chemical pathways that drove sugar synthesis in extraterrestrial environments. 

Interestingly, comparing the relative abundance of these extraterrestrial sugars with those produced by the formose reaction under laboratory conditions revealed a resemblance (Figure 1). When heated under a prolonged period of time (390 minutes), it was found that formation of linear aldopentoses was favoured over unwanted branched ketoses (Furukawa et al. 2026). This shift in the distribution of products, along with the similarity between the relative abundance of sugars found on Bennu, demonstrates that prebiotic sugar synthesis may have been more favourable in the warm, alkaline aqueous environments of asteroid bodies.

Figure 1. (A) The concentrations of aldopentoses in a formose-like reaction product conducted with 100 mM formaldehyde, 10 mM glycolaldehyde dissolved in ammonia buffer (pH 9.6) at 90ºC (Furukawa et al. 2019). (B) Relative abundances of pentoses in Bennu compared to that observed in  the formose-type reaction in (A) (Furukawa et al. 2026).

Ultimately, these findings demonstrate the plausibility of the formose reaction occurring outside of Earth, opening up another avenue for sugar synthesis beyond terrestrial environments. Given the recency of these discoveries, more research is needed to accurately determine the reasons why sugar synthesis was more favourable on asteroids bodies than on early Earth. Nonetheless, the case study of prebiotic sugars exemplifies how the underlying reaction does not necessarily need to change, but only where and when it takes place. 

References

Benner, Steven A., Hyo-Joong Kim, and Matthew A. Carrigan. 2012. “Asphalt, Water, and the Prebiotic Synthesis of Ribose, Ribonucleosides, and RNA.” Accounts of Chemical Research 45 (12): 2025–34. https://doi.org/10.1021/ar200332w. 

Furukawa, Yoshihiro, Yoshito Chikaraishi, Naohiko Ohkouchi, et al. 2019. “Extraterrestrial Ribose and Other Sugars in Primitive Meteorites.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 116 (49): 24440–45. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1907169116. 

Furukawa, Yoshihiro, Sako Sunami, Yoshinori Takano, et al. 2026. “Bio-Essential Sugars in Samples from Asteroid Bennu.” Nature Geoscience 19 (1): 19–24. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41561-025-01838-6. 

Higgs, Paul G., and Niles Lehman. 2015. “The RNA World: Molecular Cooperation at the Origins of Life.” Nature Reviews Genetics 16 (1): 7–17. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrg3841. 

Krishnamurthy, Ramanarayanan, and Charles Liotta. 2023. “The Potential of Glyoxylate as a Prebiotic Source Molecule and a Reactant in Protometabolic Pathways—The Glyoxylose Reaction.” Chem 9 (4): 784–97. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chempr.2023.03.007. 

Omran, Arthur. 2023. “Plausibility of the Formose Reaction in Alkaline Hydrothermal Vent Environments.” Origins of Life and Evolution of Biospheres 53 (1): 113–25. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11084-020-09599-5. 

Omran, Arthur, Cesar Menor-Salvan, Greg Springsteen, and Matthew Pasek. 2020. “The Messy Alkaline Formose Reaction and Its Link to Metabolism.” Life 10 (8): 125. https://doi.org/10.3390/life10080125. 

Comments

5 Responses to “Sweet! A Look into The Origin of Sugars ”

  1. Myan Nguyen Avatar
    Myan Nguyen

    Hi iSci!

    I was inspired to write about this after a discussion about the emergence of carbohydrates in my organic chemistry class, which I thought connected very nicely to RP1 and a little bit of HotE. Thanks for reading and any feedback is greatly appreciated 🙂

    Myan

  2. Kaiya Shaw Avatar
    Kaiya Shaw

    Hi Myan!
    I really liked your intro and conclusion, I thought they made the post easier to understand (especially since I’m not super well-versed in chemistry)! Also, I thought the overview of history at the beginning was really helpful to understand the context of the post.

    A couple suggestions that I hope can help with the editing process:
    – In P3, when you mention the two studies that look at the sugars found in meteorites and asteroids, you state that the first study with the Murchison meteorite was done by Furukawa et al in 2016, but I’m not sure if it’s super clear who did the study on the Bennu asteroid. If you have space maybe consider adding something like “the same group completed a further study in 2026 on the Bennu asteroid”

    – If you have space to add it, I think it might be helpful for readers that aren’t very familiar with some chemistry terms, to give brief explanation of what linear aldopentoses are and why that is particularly relevant to formation in a warmer, alkaline environments

  3. Sydney Shepherd Avatar
    Sydney Shepherd

    Hi Myan,

    I really enjoyed reading your blog post! It was very well written, and the topic is one I have never heard of before but find intriguing. I have a few suggestions to improve your post:

    – Remove the space after ‘sugars” in P3S3
    – In P4S2 I would change “When heated under…” to “when heated for…”

    Other than those small things your post looks awesome! Good luck editing,

    Sydney

  4. Aarav Goel Avatar
    Aarav Goel

    Hi Myan!

    I really liked learning about the origins of carbohydrates through your blog post, it was really interesting considering we’ve done a lot of research into prebiotic chemistry through RP1.

    I had a few suggestions for you:
    1. In the Bennu paragraph you wrote “biologically relevant sugars .”, you could remove the extra space between “sugars .”
    2. In the conclusion you wrote “on asteroids bodies”, you could just write “on asteroids”.
    3. In the paragraph before figure 1, your sentence leaves what was heated unclear. You could start with “After heating the mixture for 390 minutes, the researchers found that…” instead.

    Happy editing!
    Aarav

  5. Maya Knight Avatar
    Maya Knight

    Hi Myan!
    I found your blog post super interesting; you get your point across very well, in a way that is easy for the readers to follow. I have a few small suggestions:
    – In P1, your first sentence is a little long; it still conveys the point very well, but it might be easier on the eyes as two sentences. You also do a similar thing in the first sentence of P2, but I don’t think it’s a very big concern.
    – I know that at the end, you concluded there would need to be more research to accurately determine the reasons why sugar formation is more favourable on asteroids. However, if your word count allows it, it would be interesting if you included your own hypothesis for why you think this may be the case based on your research. Or if you included what research you thought should be done to find these answers.

    Happy editing!
    Maya

Leave a Reply