Addicted to DNA

You want to quit: you’d be happier, you’d be more productive, you could leave this horrible bioreactor and pursue your dreams. But you can’t. Your co-worker tried to go cold turkey and had withdrawal symptoms so bad they disintegrated in minutes. You curse the day you first tried that plasmid. Wait, what’s going on?

Bacteria can become addicted to DNA, specifically mobile gene elements called plasmids. Plasmids are rings of DNA that are separate from a bacteria’s main chromosome. A bacterium will maintain a number of replicates of a given plasmid, called the plasmid copy number (PCN). These copies can be transferred to the bacteria’s daughter cells when it undergoes binary fission (vertical transfer) (Tsang 2017).

However, since there is a finite number of plasmids in a bacterium, when it divides there is a chance that one of the bacteria’s daughters will contain zero copies of the plasmids from the parent cell. This effect (called asymmetric partitioning) is amplified with large plasmids (100 kilobases or more) since they tend to have a lower PCN. Since plasmids slow replication times and are metabolically expensive to copy and transcribe, the daughter cells without plasmids would eventually outcompete those who retained the plasmid. This would eventually eliminate the plasmid from a bacterial population, resulting in the phenomenon known as plasmid loss (Tsang 2017).

Plasmids have evolved clever mechanisms to mitigate plasmid loss. One of these methods is Plasmid Addiction Systems (PASs), which ensures a bacteria stays “addicted” to the plasmid. The toxin-antitoxin (TA) PAS consists of an operon which encodes for both a long-lived toxin and short-lived antitoxin which is rapidly degraded in the bacterial cytoplasm. Under normal conditions the bacteria will constantly create excess anti-toxin to nullify the toxin’s effect. However, when the bacteria divides, if one of its daughter cells doesn’t contain a copy of the plasmid, the anti-toxin will rapidly disappear but the longer-lasting toxin will persist from the parent, killing the cell (Figure 1). Thus only plasmid containing daughters will survive (Tsang 2017).

Figure 1. Overview of the toxin-antitoxin plasmid addiction system. Specific toxin-antitoxin mechanisms include cell-wall destroying proteins and anti-toxin enzymes, antisense mRNAs that bind to and disable complementary mRNA that would otherwise be translated into toxic proteins, and endonucleases that cleave DNA and cause double strand breaks, produced alongside methyltransferase which protects the DNA. In all these systems, the anti-toxin is much shorter lived than the toxin (Tsang 2017).

Plasmids can be both helpful and harmful. Horizontal transfer of plasmids encoding for antibiotic resistance poses a major global health risk (Darphorn et al. 2021). However, plasmids can also be introduced into a bacteria to allow the bacteria to synthesize useful compounds in bioreactors. For example, the E.coli strain BL21(DE3) was modified by introducing a plasmid that encodes for phloroglucinol (PG). PG is a useful polyketide with over 700 pharmaceutical and industrial applications. Unfortunately, the artificial synthesis of PG products involves fossil fuel feedstocks, and has major safety and pollution concerns (Singh et al. 2010). The new biosynthesis pathway (Figure 2) is safer and cleaner, but suffered from plasmid loss leading to some bacteria no longer producing PG, lowering purity and percent yield.

Figure 2. Pathway by which E.coli had genes inserted via plasmids to produce phloroglucinol. This pathway uses low-cost acetate and has better atom economy than synthetic alternatives (Xu et al. 2017).

Researchers mitigated this by introducing an antibiotic resistance gene to the plasmid then saturating the bioreactor with antibiotics, thereby selecting for bacteria with the plasmid. However this is expensive and not always effective. Therefore, a new study introduced a PAS to the plasmid which reduced plasmid loss and increased PG production without the use of antibiotics (Wang et al. 2024). Others have developed toxin-antitoxin PAS using missense mRNA as an antitoxin to improve industrial fermentation of amino-acids (Li et al. 2018). The field is still evolving, with researchers finding new ways to addict bacteria to improve biosynthesis chemistry.

References

Darphorn, Tania S., Keshia Bel, Belinda B. Koenders-van Sint Anneland, Stanley Brul, and Benno H. Ter Kuile. 2021. “Antibiotic Resistance Plasmid Composition and Architecture in Escherichia Coli Isolates from Meat.” Scientific Reports 11 (1): 2136. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-81683-w.

Li, Ya-jie, Ya Liu, Zheng Zhang, Xiao-jing Chen, Ya Gong, and Yue-zhong Li. 2018. “A Post-Segregational Killing Mechanism for Maintaining Plasmid PMF1 in Its Myxococcus Fulvus Host.” Frontiers in Cellular and Infection Microbiology 8 (August): 274. https://doi.org/10.3389/fcimb.2018.00274.

Singh, Inder Pal, Jasmeen Sidana, Sandip B. Bharate, and William J. Foley. 2010. “Phloroglucinol Compounds of Natural Origin: Synthetic Aspects.” Natural Product Reports 27 (3): 393–416. https://doi.org/10.1039/b914364p.

Tsang, Jennifer. 2017. “Bacterial Plasmid Addiction Systems and Their Implications for Antibiotic Drug Development.” Postdoc Journal : A Journal of Postdoctoral Research and Postdoctoral Affairs 5 (5): 3–9.

Wang, Ji-ming, Yu-jin Cao, Xiao Men, and Hai-bo Zhang. 2024. “Construction of a grpE-Based Plasmid Addiction System in Escherichia Coli and Its Application in Phloroglucinol Biosynthesis.” Journal of Applied Microbiology 135 (5): lxae116. https://doi.org/10.1093/jambio/lxae116.

Xu, Xin, Mo Xian, and Huizhou Liu. 2017. “Efficient Conversion of Acetate into Phloroglucinol by Recombinant Escherichia Coli.” RSC Advances 7 (80): 50942–48. https://doi.org/10.1039/c7ra09519h.

Comments

4 Responses to “Addicted to DNA”

  1. Gavin Lee Avatar
    Gavin Lee

    Hi all!
    Inspired by the paper by Koonin on parasitic mobile gene elements that we read in life sciences. Any advice/help welcome.
    – Gavin

  2. Veer Jain Avatar
    Veer Jain

    Hey Gavin,

    I thought this was a really engaging post! The hook was funny and the topic itself is super interesting. I had a few suggestions:

    – The transition into the scientific explanation in the intro feels a little abrupt. Consider adding one sentence after “Wait, what’s going on?” to more smoothly connect the imagined scenario to plasmids and plasmid addiction.
    – Figure 1 is helpful, but the caption is pretty dense. You might want to shorten it so the main takeaway stands out more clearly, since a lot of the extra details could stay in the body of the text instead.
    – Figure 2 is quite technical, so it may help to briefly explain in the paragraph what the “upper” and “lower” pathways are showing.
    – Small thing: Sometimes you say “a bacteria” where it should be “a bacterium,”

    Overall, great work and good luck on your final draft!
    Veer

  3. Grace Lorenz Avatar
    Grace Lorenz

    Hi Gavin!

    This was an awesome blog post! I loved the intro and it made me want to continue reading. My only suggestion is to centre your figures and captions to improve the appearance of the post.

    Overall, great job!
    Grace

  4. Alice Buckley Avatar
    Alice Buckley

    Hi Gavin,

    Really interesting blog post! I had no idea plasmids could be addictive, this sounds pretty incredible.

    I had a few minor edits:
    – Consider centering the figures
    – P5S4: Italicize E. Coli
    – P6: the second half of the paragraph seemed a bit rushed, consider elaborating on your conclusion and making it its own paragraph

    I look forward to reading your final blog post!
    Alice

Leave a Reply