In May of 1902, Mount Pelée, a stratovolcano, destroyed the city of Saint-Pierre, Martinique. The volcano erupted, released a deadly cloud of superheated gases, ash, and volcanic debris, and led to the death of approximately 30,000 people(Fisher and Heiken 1982).
Months prior to the catastrophic event, the volcano showed increasingly concerning signs of activity including earthquakes, ash emissions, and smaller explosions (Salmon 2021). Despite this activity, many people remained in the city and the population actually increased due to rural refugees moving inward in the weeks leading up to the explosion (Norton 2002). This raises an interesting question: why did so many people remain in the path of danger? While geological processes produced the warning signs, psychological mechanisms may help explain how people interpreted them.
In 1792 and 1851, Mount Pelée had experienced minor eruptions and this history may have influenced how residents interpreted the warning signs in 1902, specifically causing them to underestimate the severity of the threat (Salmon 2021). This behaviour can also be explained through the normalcy bias which is a cognitive tendency to underestimate danger by assuming that future events will resemble past experiences (Lauren Braithwaite 2023). The fumarolic (openings in the Earth’s surface that release volcanic gases and steam) activity intensified between January and mid-April 1902 but since the individuals in the city previously encountered a potentially dangerous situation without experiencing serious consequences, they were unlikely to recognize the severity of this situation (Andrews 2026). As time passed, Mount Pelée had begun producing phreatic eruptions, (explosions caused when groundwater is rapidly heated by volcanic activity) and earthquakes occurred more often. Although these geological processes indicated increasing volcanic unrest, individuals may have compared the activity to previous, less destructive events which caused a misleading sense of security.
On May 5, Mount Pelée was responsible for a destructive volcanic mudflow, known as a lahar, that swept down the mountainside and destroyed a sugar-processing facility, killing workers (Rosen 2015). By May 7, Mount Pelée’s activity had intensified further and the volcanic system progressed from primarily steam-driven explosions toward magmatic eruptions. Despite the escalating activity, many residents remained in the city. Their decisions may have been influenced not only by their own perceptions of danger but also by the behaviour of those around them. This phenomenon is known as social proof, which is a psychological mechanism in which individuals look to others’ behaviour to determine how they should behave, specifically during situations with uncertainty (Pilat and Krastev 2021). When no one took protective action in Saint Pierre, individuals may have interpreted this collective behaviour as evidence that the situation is relatively safe.
At approximately 8 a.m. on May 8, Mount Pelée unleashed a devastating pyroclastic density current that swept through Saint-Pierre (Salmon 2021). More than a century later, volcanic monitoring has advanced dramatically. However, improved geological knowledge does not eliminate the psychological challenges of disaster preparedness. This historical event demonstrates that effective disaster preparedness requires geological clues and understanding the psychological and social factors that influence whether people act on them.
References
Andrews, Paul. 2026. “Martinique’s Mt. Pelée Volcano Eruption of 1902 – LOST IN HISTORY.” November 2. https://lost-in-history.com/martiniques-mt-pelee-volcano-eruption-of-1902/.
Fisher, Richard V., and Grant Heiken. 1982. “Mt. Pelée, Martinique: May 8 and 20, 1902, Pyroclastic Flows and Surges.” Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research 13 (3): 339–71. https://doi.org/10.1016/0377-0273(82)90056-7.
Lauren Braithwaite (The Decision Lab). 2023. “Normalcy Bias.” December 11. https://thedecisionlab.com/biases/normalcy-bias.
Norton, G. G. (History Today). 2002. “The Eruption of La Montagne Pelée.” April 30. https://www.historytoday.com/archive/months-past/eruption-la-montagne-pelee.
Pilat, Dan, and Sekoul Krastev (The Decision Lab). 2021. “Social Proof.” February 17. https://thedecisionlab.com/reference-guide/psychology/social-proof.
Rosen, Julia (EARTH Magazine). 2015. “Benchmarks: May 8, 1902: The Deadly Eruption of Mount Pelée.” April 7. https://www.earthmagazine.org/article/benchmarks-may-8-1902-deadly-eruption-mount-pelee/.
Salmon, Virginia L. (Mount Pelée Erupts). 2021. “Mount Pelée Erupts | History | Research Starters | EBSCOhost.” https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/history/mount-pelee-erupts/.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.