Do Crows Hold Grudges? The Bird That Never Forgets a Face

Imagine walking to a class when a crow suddenly starts screaming at you. You haven’t done anything wrong, at least not today. Maybe you accidently scared it months ago, and now it has decided you’re an enemy for life. It sounds ridiculous, but what if crows really could remember the people who wronged them? Research suggests these birds have an extraordinary ability to recognize threatening faces, and they might even warn their friends about them.

To investigate this, researchers at the University of Washington conducted an unusual experiment. They wore distinctive masks while capturing, banding, and releasing American crows. Later, people wearing the same masks returned to the area, alongside others wearing neutral masks. The birds responded differently depending on which face they saw. Crows directed harsh alarm calls, known as scolding, towards the threatening masks and sometimes gathered in groups to follow the wearer. Remarkably, they could recognize the dangerous face even when someone else was wearing it (Marzluff et al. 2010).

However, remembering a face is only part of the story. Researchers discovered that the proportion of crows scolding the threatening mask increased from 26% shortly after trapping to 66% approximately 2.7 years later (Cornell, Marzluff, and Pecoraro 2012). As figure 1 illustrates, recognition of the perceived threat persisted and became more widespread rather than disappearing with time.

Figure 1. American crows’ scolding responses in relation to time since trapping (a), exposure to the threatening mask (b), and exposure to the neutral mask (c). Responses to the threatening mask increased, supporting the persistence and social spread of threat recognition. Source: Cornell, Marzluff, and Pecoraro (2012).

So how did more crows recognize a dangerous face when most had never been captured? The explanation involves social learning, which occurs when animals acquire information by observing others. Researchers observed young crows joining their parents in scolding the threatening mask. More surprisingly, some crows that had never been captured responded to the mask while alone, suggesting they had learned to recognize it from earlier encounters with other birds (Cornell, Marzluff, and Pecoraro 2012). Essentially, a crow could learn to distrust someone without having a bad experience with that person. 

The mystery becomes even more fascinating when we look inside their brains. Using brain imaging, Marzluff et al. (2012) found that threatening human faces activated regions associated with attention, fear, and defensive behaviour. This suggests that recognizing a dangerous individual involves coordinated neurological responses rather than simply reacting to an unfamiliar appearance. Nevertheless, describing this behaviour as holding a grudge raises an important distinction. The experiments demonstrate long term memory and social learning, but they cannot establish whether crows experience resentment like humans do. Recognizing threats may instead be an evolutionary advantage that helps them avoid danger. 

Perhaps the real surprise isn’t that crows remember threatening people, but that their knowledge can spread to birds that were never harmed. So, the next time a crow starts yelling at someone on campus, maybe it isn’t just making noise. Maybe that person reputation has already made its way through the neighbourhood.

References

Cornell, Heather N., John M. Marzluff, and Shannon Pecoraro. 2012. “Social Learning Spreads Knowledge about Dangerous Humans among American Crows.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 279 (1728): 499–508. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2011.0957.

Marzluff, John M., Robert Miyaoka, Satoshi Minoshima, and Donna J. Cross. 2012. “Brain Imaging Reveals Neuronal Circuitry Underlying the Crow’s Perception of Human Faces.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109 (39): 15912–15917. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1206109109.

Marzluff, John M., Jeff Walls, Heather N. Cornell, John C. Withey, and David P. Craig. 2010. “Lasting Recognition of Threatening People by Wild American Crows.” Animal Behaviour 79 (3): 699–707. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anbehav.2009.12.022

Comments

6 Responses to “Do Crows Hold Grudges? The Bird That Never Forgets a Face”

  1. Nastaho Mohamed Avatar
    Nastaho Mohamed

    Hi Isci!
    For my second SciLit blog, I wanted to explore something very interseting: whether crows can actually hold grudges. I found it fascinating that these birds can recognize threatening human faces years later and even pass that information on to other crows. It made me curious about how animal memory and social learning work, and whether what we call a “grudge” might actually be a survival strategy.
    I hope you enjoy reading it, and I’m looking forward to hearing your thoughts!

    – Nastaho Mohamed

  2. Kaiya Shaw Avatar
    Kaiya Shaw

    Hi Nastaho,

    This was a really cool post! I thought your intro was really well done and definitely hooked me to read more.

    A couple suggestions to hopefully help with your editing:

    – Make sure to centre your figure and figure caption

    – Super small thing, but change “person” to “person’s” in the final sentence of the post

    – In paragraph 2, I think you might either be missing in-text citations, or if all of the information is from Marzluff et al. 2010, you should cite that directly after the first sentence instead at the end of all of the information

    Overall, Great work! This was a really interesting idea, and I definitely learned something new 🙂

    Kaiya

  3. Rasmus Howson Creutzberg Avatar
    Rasmus Howson Creutzberg

    Hi Nastaho!

    I really like this blogpost topic! There are so many interesting perspectives you could take and you picked a fun one!

    When it comes to feedback I think that you could create a more cohesive flow and narrative to address a specific question. You mention the question about weather crows can recognize faces, and then answer it in your introduction which could work as a starting point, but you then proceed to summarize the research instead of expanding the question. It is important to consider that a blog post is supposed to synthesis and integrate two perspectives and link them to things we have learned in iSci which you are supposed to mention in your comment. Finally be sure to use the correct intext citation format in figure captions. To expand the scope of your blogpost you should consult more then these three sources.

    Best of luck editing!

    Rasmus

  4. Maybel Wang Avatar
    Maybel Wang

    Hi Nastaho,

    This was a very interesting topic! I enjoyed reading more about whether crows holds grudges. Here are some minor suggestions I have:

    – If word count allows, consider going into more detail on the activated brain regions and why this happens. This could help make your blog post more integrative
    – Citation in figure caption should be structured like an in-text citation, i.e. (Cornell et al. 2012)
    – very minor thing, but try to not only center your figure and figure caption, but also make the figure caption a smaller font size and italicized to differentiate it from the rest of the text.

    Overall, this was a great blog post! I look forward to the final edit

    Maybel

  5. Albesa Fazliu Avatar
    Albesa Fazliu

    Hi Nastaho,

    Interesting topic! I thoroughly enjoyed reading about crows and their potential to harbour grudges as humans do. Here are some suggestions if you would like to implement them:

    – This is more of a stylistic choice, but your transition to paragraph three: “However, remembering a face is only part of the story”, could be changed to be a bit more formal.
    – In paragraph 5, the sentence “Nevertheless, describing this behaviour as holding a grudge raises an important distinction.” is introduced but stops at a full period, I would elaborate while continuing the sentence.
    – Decrease the font size of your figure caption! Also, I would remove “Source:” when inputting your in-text citation for your figure as it’s not needed.
    – Make sure your in-text citations stay consistent throughout, you use brackets around the entire citation sometimes and brackets around the year only for other times. Another suggestion for your citations is that (Cornell, Marzluff, and Pecoraro 2012) should be (Cornell et al. 2012) which stays true for any source that has multiple authors.

    I can’t wait to see your final version. Happy editing!

    Albesa Fazliu

  6. Kimi Wong Avatar
    Kimi Wong

    Hi Nastaho,

    This was such an interesting read! I knew crows seemed to hold grudges, but I never looked into the science as to why. Here are some potential suggestions to consider:

    – A little nitpicky, but your first sentence flows strangely. Consider reading it aloud and rewritting it if it also sounds odd to you
    – Your figure caption should be adjusted to not match the body text

    Can’t wait to see how your final post turns out! Happy editing!

    Kimi Wong

Leave a Reply