It’s All in the Mind: How Wine Taste is Shaped

Imagine a glass of wine at an expensive restaurant, then compare that wine on a regular evening at home. The actual wine has not changed, but the perceptions and anticipations surrounding it has. Wine is not only experienced through taste and smell, psychological expectations and emotions also influence the overall enjoyment of it. In psychology, top-down processing is when the brain uses pre-existing knowledge and expectations to interpret sensory information (Gaspelin & Luck 2018). 

Olfactory-oral cross-modal interactions is when smell influences the perceptions of how something tastes (Pittari et al. 2020). Due to the tongue being limited to basic taste inputs like sweet, sour, and bitter, most of the perception of wine flavour comes from smell. In fact, the sense of smell can account for over 75% of food flavour judgments that shape expectations of wine taste (Yuan et al. 2024). A study in rats showed that alcohol can indirectly activate dopamine release in the nucleus accumbens through the stimulation of endogenous opioid peptides (Chiara 1997). Dopamine is known as the brain’s pleasure chemical that also plays a role in motivation and learning which experiences are rewarding.

The taste of wine is inherently subjective as many factors such as price and context influence perceptions. A study by Schmidt et al (2017) investigates how the price of wine alters the brain’s valuation system to translate expectations into sensory pleasantness. Participants were told that wine samples had different prices despite being identical and rated how pleasant each wine tasted while undergoing an fMRI brain scan. The wines believed to be more expensive were perceived as more enjoyable, with the ventromedial prefrontal cortex and ventral striatum becoming more active. These regions are the brain’s valuation system responsible for converting expectations into the experienced value (Schmidt et al. 2017). Labels, packaging, and brand names can also influence perceptions. This suggests that price does not only change how a person perceives wine but also impacts the experience itself. 

Beyond price and expectation, wine can also evoke memories and emotions. Two memory processes are encoding and consolidation, where a memory is created and stored (Weafer et al. 2016). Alcohol can affect these memory processes, as participants that consumed alcohol after learning something showed improved overall memory. Those who are more sensitive to the rewarding effects are more likely to have memories associated with alcohol-related stimuli. Memories can also be triggered by smell due to the uniqueness of the olfactory system. Unlike other sensory systems, the sense of smell bypasses the thalamus and is relayed directly to the limbic system (Sullivan et al. 2015). The distinct power of olfaction to influence mood along with the hundreds of aromatic compounds in wine can lead to different aromas becoming associated with particular memories.  

Wine tasting is a multisensory experience that goes beyond just taste and aroma, with many processes in the brain shaping perception and experience. The same wine can create vastly different experiences from person to person based on individual expectations and memories. After all, the most memorable part of wine may not be what is in it, but what it reminds someone of.

References

Chiara, Gaetano Di. 1997. “Alcohol and Dopamine.” Alcohol Health and Research World 21 (2): 108. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6826820/.

Gaspelin, Nicholas, and Steven J. Luck. 2018. “‘Top-Down’ Does Not Mean ‘Voluntary.’” Journal of Cognition 1 (1): 25. https://doi.org/10.5334/joc.28.

Pittari, Elisabetta, Luigi Moio, Panagiotis Arapitsas, et al. 2020. “Exploring Olfactory-Oral Cross-Modal Interactions Through Sensory and Chemical Characteristics of Italian Red Wines.” Foods (Basel, Switzerland) (Switzerland) 9 (11): 1530. PubMed Central. https://doi.org/10.3390/foods9111530.

Schmidt, Liane, Vasilisa Skvortsova, Claus Kullen, Bernd Weber, and Hilke Plassmann. 2017. “How Context Alters Value: The Brain’s Valuation and Affective Regulation System Link Price Cues to Experienced Taste Pleasantness.” Scientific Reports 7 (1): 8098. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-017-08080-0.

Sullivan, Regina M., Donald A. Wilson, Nadine Ravel, and Anne-Marie Mouly. 2015. “Olfactory Memory Networks: From Emotional Learning to Social Behaviors.” Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience 9 (36). https://doi.org/10.3389/fnbeh.2015.00036.

Weafer, Jessica, David A. Gallo, and Harriet de Wit. 2016. “Effect of Alcohol on Encoding and Consolidation of Memory for Alcohol-Related Images.” Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research 40 (7): 1540–47. https://doi.org/10.1111/acer.13103.

Yuan, Weixi, Fumei Guo, Mimi Li, and Haiyan Song. 2024. “Effects of Sensory Cues on Consumers’ Wine Taste Perceptions and Behavior: Evidence From a Wine-Tasting Experiment.” International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management 36 (12): 4171–91. https://doi.org/10.1108/ijchm-08-2023-1160.

Comments

4 Responses to “It’s All in the Mind: How Wine Taste is Shaped”

  1. Maybel Wang Avatar
    Maybel Wang

    Hi iSci,

    My group focused a lot on the perceptions of wine for our research project. I wanted to take this opportunity to research and expand more on this topic.

    I hope you enjoy reading and I look forward to your comments!

  2. Emily Tai Avatar
    Emily Tai

    Hi Maybel!

    I really enjoyed reading your blogpost! I thought it was very interesting how you connected the taste of wine to its psychological effects. Here’s some feedback to improve your post.

    I think it would be helpful to add a figure or image that supports your topic. For example, when you mention the study by Schmidt et al. and the parts of the brain that lit up, it would be nice to include the fMRI brain scans so readers can see which regions were active.

    I also think the rat study could be linked more clearly to wine. The post says alcohol triggers dopamine release in rats, but does not say how this relates to people enjoying wine. A short sentence connecting the two would help readers follow why it is included.

    Finally, there are a few small grammar mistakes. In P1S2, “has” should be “have” since the subject is plural and in P2S1, “interactions is” should be “interactions are” for the same reason. In P5S3, “Afterall” should also be changed to “After all.”

    Overall, this was a very well written post, and I look forward to reading your final draft!
    Emily Tai

  3. Troy Lin Avatar
    Troy Lin

    Hi Maybel,

    I really enjoyed reading your blog post. I liked how you showed that price doesn’t just change how people rate wine but actually changes how the brain responds to it. I have some suggestions that would make your blog a lot stronger.

    – I think you should try include a figure
    – P1S2, “the perceptions and anticipations surrounding it has” should be “have,” since the subject is plural.
    – In P5S3, “Afterall” should be two words so “After all.”

    Overall it was a really interesting read and good luck with editing.
    Troy Lin

  4. Brianna Yankson Avatar
    Brianna Yankson

    Hi Maybel,

    This was a very interesting blog post topic. The only suggestion I have is to maybe add a transition in your second paragraph from smell to dopamine release in rats to make it flow better.

    Overall, this blog post was very well written, and it was exciting to know more about perceptions of wine.
    Brianna

Leave a Reply