Lakes are like onions, they have layers.

There are so many different lakes found on earth, from giant lakes created by scars left by glaciers, such as the Canadian great lakes, to tiny lakes such as Crawford Lake also located in Canada. While they both look identical, apart to their size to each other on the surface, these two examples are wildly different when it comes to what’s below.

Starting off with the great lakes, they are what is known as Holozoic. Holozoic lakes apply to lakes that have circulating water, from top to bed, when the lake cools and warms (Allaby 2020a). They have two distinct layers the epilimnion, which is the upper, warmer, circulating stratified layer (Allaby 2020b), and hypolimnion which is the lower, colder, non-circulating stratified layer (Allaby 2020c). These are your basic dime, a dozen lakes that comprise almost all lakes on earth. And granted while they are different types of holozoic lakes, we have a more interesting type of lake to talk about.

Figure 1: Sketch of a Meromictic lake (Boehrer et al. 2017)

Meromictic lakes are lakes who have permanently stratified water layers due to a chemical difference that cause them two have two different densities between the epilimnion and hypolimnion waters (Allaby 2020d). Unlike holozoic lakes, they have three distinct layers. There is the monimolimnion (the deeper layer, similar to hypolimnion), the mixolimnion (the upper layer, similar to epilimnion) and the boundary layer named the chemocline which separates the two layers (Zadereev et al. 2017) (See figure 1). It is important to point the major difference in holozoic lakes and meromictic lakes by the difference in the monimolimnion layer and how it differs from regular hypolimnion layers. They differ by the fact that monimolimnion are not stagnant and are constantly shifting due to pressure differences and that it has a constant flow and uptake from ground waters(Zadereev et al. 2017). Additionally, most of the time monimolimnion has an anoxic environment allowing for it to be colonized by diverse microzooplankton and microbial communities(Zadereev et al. 2017).

Notic how I said most? Almost all the the very rare meromictic lakes differ in and that’s what makes them special. Lake Crawford as an example is actually the opposite. It has an highly oxygenated hypolimnion level (when compared to others), that’s well above the hypoxic limit (Llew-Williams et al. 2024). This is because of the well- oxygenated ground water that leaks into the lake (Llew-Williams et al. 2024).

Each meromictic lake is different with what each layer is comprised of. They range from very low (<20g/L), to very high saturation (>300 g/L) (Schultze et al. 2017), to being very acidic to very alkaline (Schultze et al. 2017). Another example is Hot Lake (USA), which is a shallow lake that has an almost 100% saturation of soluble salts (Schultze et al. 2017) which differs physically from Crawford lake which is a 24m deep sink hole (Llew-Williams et al. 2024).

From these examples, we can see how much verity there is found within these types of lakes. Not only that, but they can help us research so many different things due to there unique environments such as researching anaerobic life!

References:

Allaby, Michael. 2020a. “Meromictic.” In A Dictionary of Geology and Earth Sciences. Oxford University Press. https://www.oxfordreference.com/display/10.1093/acref/9780198839033.001.0001/acref-9780198839033-e-5177.

Allaby, Michael. 2020b. “Hypolimnion.” In A Dictionary of Geology and Earth Sciences. Oxford University Press. https://www.oxfordreference.com/display/10.1093/acref/9780198839033.001.0001/acref-9780198839033-e-4084.

Allaby, Michael. 2020c. “Epilimnion.” In A Dictionary of Geology and Earth Sciences. Oxford University Press. https://www.oxfordreference.com/display/10.1093/acref/9780198839033.001.0001/acref-9780198839033-e-2781.

Allaby, Michael. 2020d. “Holomictic.” In A Dictionary of Geology and Earth Sciences. Oxford University Press. https://www.oxfordreference.com/display/10.1093/acref/9780198839033.001.0001/acref-9780198839033-e-3925.

Boehrer, Bertram, Christoph von Rohden, and Martin Schultze. 2017. “Physical Features of Meromictic Lakes: Stratification and Circulation.” In Ecology of Meromictic Lakes, edited by Ramesh D. Gulati, Egor S. Zadereev, and Andrei G. Degermendzhi. Springer International Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-49143-1_2.

Llew-Williams, Brendan M., Francine M. G. McCarthy, Andrea M. Krueger, et al. 2024. “Quantifying Conditions Required for Varve Formation in Meromictic Crawford Lake, Ontario, Canada: Important Process for Delimiting the Anthropocene Epoch.” Journal of Paleolimnology 71 (2): 101–24. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10933-023-00304-w.

Schultze, Martin, Bertram Boehrer, Katrin Wendt-Potthoff, Sergei Katsev, and Erik T. Brown. 2017. “Chemical Setting and Biogeochemical Reactions in Meromictic Lakes.” In Ecology of Meromictic Lakes, edited by Ramesh D. Gulati, Egor S. Zadereev, and Andrei G. Degermendzhi. Springer International Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-49143-1_3.

Zadereev, Egor S., Bertram Boehrer, and Ramesh D. Gulati. 2017. “Introduction: Meromictic Lakes, Their Terminology and Geographic Distribution.” In Ecology of Meromictic Lakes, edited by Ramesh D. Gulati, Egor S. Zadereev, and Andrei G. Degermendzhi. Springer International Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-49143-1_1.

Comments

6 Responses to “Lakes are like onions, they have layers.”

  1. Kai Fusch Avatar
    Kai Fusch

    Hi iSci!

    After learning about lake Vostok with Chad, the whole concept of meromictic lakes fascinated me, and I wanted to learn all about them. That’s when I learned about all the different types of meromictic lakes out there and I knew this is the topic I wanted to discuss!
    I wanted to explore the Earth science of how they were structured and the chemistry on just how much they vary in for pH (from acidic to basic) and their saturation levels.

    I hope you enjoy learning about them as much as I did and I can’t wait to incorporate your feedback!
    – Kai Fusch

  2. Lily McCormick Avatar
    Lily McCormick

    Hello Kai,

    Good post, it was interesting to learn about meromictic lakes. I just have a few points for improvement:

    1. In the last sentence of the intro paragraph, you use the contraction “what’s”. I would avoid this and use more formal language. Throughout the post, I would consider sounding more formal as well, although this is a stylistic choice and you may decide against it!
    2. There are typos in P2 line 3 (Abbey 2020) and P4 line 1 (notice).
    3. You should format the text below your figure to be a caption (there is a feature for this in synopsis). Additionally, you should add more information to describe what is happening in the figure, rather than simply naming it.
    4. In your citations, links should only be provided if it is a doi.

    Again, great job! I look forward to reading the edited version,
    Lily

  3. Joycee Joseph Avatar
    Joycee Joseph

    Hi Kai,

    This is a very well written post, I love the angle that you took on this topic! A few suggestions to polish your blog:
    – Your opening sentence is a bit long right now, try to break it up for smoother flow.
    – ‘great lakes’ should be “Great Lakes,’ they are also called the Laurentian Great Lakes.
    – Format your title for references as a subheading, with no colon.
    – In P2S2, move your citations to the end as ((Allaby 2020b; Allaby 2020c) to improve readability.
    – If word count permits, you should add more to your concluding paragraph, to leave the readers with some final thoughts.
    Great job overall, I can’t wait to read the final product!

    Joycee

  4. Celine Hamze Avatar
    Celine Hamze

    Hi Kai, this was a really interesting blog post! Below is some feedback that you could consider:

    -Make sure to capitalize the first letters of the words in your title

    -title doesn’t need a period!

    -P1S1: “to tiny ones such as Crawford Lake…”

    -P1S2: “While they both look identical (apart from their size) on the surface, these two examples are wildly different when it comes to what’s below.”

    -make sure to mention figure 1 in the text before it appears

    -make the references title larger 🙂

    Overall, great job! Happy editing!

    Celine

  5. Heer Upadhyay Avatar
    Heer Upadhyay

    Hi Kai,

    Awesome blog post! I love your topic on the layers of different lakes and how you connected it to the chemical composition of each one!

    Some suggestions:
    –P1S2: When you say “apart to their size to each other” I think the wording is a bit confusing. If you mean that they are the same in size, maybe you could replace “to” with “from” after apart.
    –P2S2: “They have two distinct layers: the epilimnion….” a colon there would fit better to break up the list.

    Overall great job, happy editing!
    Heer

  6. Amanda Vormittag Avatar
    Amanda Vormittag

    Hi Kai!

    I really liked reading your blog post and learning more about the lakes that we are lucky enough to have all around us here in Ontario! I wanted to offer the following suggestions for you during your editing period:

    – I noticed that all of your Allaby sources have the links to the Oxford Reference website but your source does have a DOI (10.1093/acref/9780198839033.001.0001) which is better to include in your references since a DOI is a permanent identifier!
    – P2S1: Instead of saying “Holozoic lakes apply to lakes…” you can just say “Holozoic lakes are lakes…”. Also in this paragraph keep in mind consistency of capitalization. Holozoic is capitalized in S1 but not in S5.
    – P3S1: Consider changing “who” to “that” in the definition of meromictic lakes, since “who” is typically used for people, whereas “that” is more appropriate for objects or places like lakes!
    – Super small thing but it appears that you are missing spaces before (Zadereev et al. 2017) in P3.

    Overall well-done, I look forward to reading the final piece!

    Amanda

Leave a Reply