Don’t Take Phosphorus for Granite!

Phosphate may be billions of years old; however, scientists have uncovered its recycling potential, making it more valuable today. Phosphorus is a mineral needed for the body to function. Not only does it contribute to all cellular processes, but it is primarily found in the bones, working hand in hand with calcium (Wickham, 2014). Phosphates are compounds that contain phosphorus and oxygen, being the backbones of DNA and RNA. 

The elements’ prevalence dates back to Earth’s Beginnings. The making of Pangea is the result of large-scale amalgamation of continents and micro-continents, which started at the end of the Neoproterozoic with the formation of Gondwana. When tectonic plates collide, ancient marine seafloor fragments are lifted and revealed, exposing rocks that are rich in Phosphorus. (Nealon, 2017). Therefore, phosphorus is a sacred, finite resource. 

A common use of Phosphate is Phosphate fertilizers, as the PO₄³⁻ in the rock reacts with Sulfuric acid to produce a Superphosphate fertilizer (Vallero, 2018). Additionally, Phosphorus is contained in beverages we know and love, such as sodas- the mineral aids in prolonging shelf life, elevating the flavour, and moisture. As individuals take in these sources of Phosphate, it ends up in sewage streams and as human waste. Recently, the average price has nearly tripled between 2005 and 2015 (Cid et al. 2018). But how can we reuse the consumed Phosphorus instead of mining for more? 

Monitoring and measuring phosphorus is vital to successfully recycle it. Data demonstrate that 20 to 50% and 35 to 55% of eutrophication is from the contribution of Nitrate and Phosphate in water bodies (Akinnawo, 2023). To elucidate, Magnesium Ammonium Phosphate Hexahydrate (MgNH₄PO₄ ⋅ 6H₂O) is a Phosphate mineral (also known as struvite) found in urine. The mineral releases nutrients that can be potentially harmful to waterways by producing algae, etc. (Gonçalves et al. 2026). With this challenge, a study collected human urine before it was lost in wastewater and stored samples at ambient temperature (average 25ºC.) The characterization of the minerals was performed using X-Ray Diffraction (XRD), quantifying different phases in the crystalline structure. Alongside the XRD, nuclear magnetic resonance was used to study the chemical environment of the Phosphorus. It was found that struvite was the main Phosphorus-containing compound. While at neutral pH, it was uncovered that 61% of Phosphorus in the recovered material dissolved in water within 10 days, supporting its potential to be reused as a nutrient and that it can be recovered from this material. This study paved the way for nutrient recovery research.

​Ultimately, when thinking of retrieving Phosphorus, understanding it’s value resulting from Pangea highlights the importance of resource recycling. Phosphorus recovery can reduce our dependence on mining and implement a cyclical process that reduces pollution in waterways and more.

References

Akinnawo, Solomon O. 2023. “Eutrophication: Causes, consequences, physical, chemical and biological techniques for mitigation strategies.” Environmental Challenges 12. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2667010023000574.

Cid, Clement A., Justin T. Jasper, and Michael R. Hoffman. 2018. “Phosphate Recovery from Human Waste via the Formation of Hydroxyapatite during Electrochemical Wastewater Treatment.” Environmental Science & Technology 52 (6): 3135–3142. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5871340/.

Gonçalves, Ricardo, Regiane Roque, Yuri Nariyoshi, Renata Estevam, and Honerio Coutinho de Jesus. 2026. “Struvite precipitation from source-separated human urine: mineralogical characterization, phosphorus release kinetics, and heavy metal safety assessment.” Environmental Science and Pollution Research 33 (5): 1639–1651. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12901090/.

Nealon, Sean. 2017. “Extreme Phosphorus Scarcity and Its Grip on Ancient Life.” NASA Biology Institute. https://astrobiology.nasa.gov/nai/articles/2017/2/16/extreme-phosphorus-scarcity-and-its-grip-on-ancient-life/index.html

Vallero, Daniel A. 2008. “Fundamentals of Air Pollution (Fourth Edition).” Air Pollution 313–355. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/chapter/monograph/abs/pii/B978012373615450011X.

Wickham, Erica. 2014. “Phosphorus Content in Commonly Consumed Beverages.” Journal of Renal Nutrition 24 (1): e1–e4. https://www.jrnjournal.org/article/s1051-2276(13)00181-7/fulltext

Comments

5 Responses to “Don’t Take Phosphorus for Granite!”

  1. Euna Kim Avatar
    Euna Kim

    Hey iSci friends!

    This blog topic on the origins of Phosphate and how it can be recycled was inspired by drinking Coca Cola! As I was checking the ingredients for this beverage, I noticed it contained Phosphoric acid. By learning about the importance and its relevance in our daily lives, that’s how it sparked my idea for this blog post.

    Understanding how Pangea affected how we mine and use phosphate today emphasizes important contents in Earth Science. Of course, Phosphate is a chemical compound which is an immediate connection to Chemistry, however relying on a sustainable chemistry lens allows us to comprehend how it can be reused. The concept can be connected to the Life Cycle Assessment method learned in class, including: environmental toxicity and eutrophication as a subcategory. Mining for this resource is valuable, and it can be an intricate process for recovery, therefore it reminds us to not take Phosphorus for granted!

    1. Jua Seok Avatar
      Jua Seok

      Hi Euna!
      I really enjoyed reading your blog post 🙂

      I loved how you connected phosphorus to both its geological origins and its importance today. The example showing that 61% of the recovered phosphorus dissolved within 10 days was especially effective because it provided clear evidence that phosphorus can potentially be recycled and reused.

      One area that could potentially be expanded on is the transition between the geological history of phosphorus and its modern uses. The discussion moves fairly quickly from Pangea and tectonic plates to phosphate fertilizers, so I think that adding a sentence explaining how these ancient phosphorus-rich rock deposits eventually become resources that humans mine today would make the connection clearer. I also think the eutrophication section could explain the environmental effects in a little more detail. You mention that nutrients can cause algae growth, but briefly explaining how that algae growth can negatively affect aquatic ecosystems would make the environmental importance of phosphorus recovery even clearer. Overall, I thought the article did a great job showing how recycling phosphorus could address both resource scarcity and environmental pollution.

  2. Farwa Rehan Avatar
    Farwa Rehan

    Hi Euna!

    Amazing blog post, I really enjoyed reading it! As someone who loves geology, your title really made me laugh! Here are a couple of suggestions that will make your post even better:

    (1) Add a figure! A picture is worth a thousand words and is a great standard practice in blog posts. It makes them more visually engaging and a figure caption is a great way to get more specific or even get around the limiting word count.
    (2) Your references should be bolded and have a different font size; reference other blog posts to see the standard practice.
    (3) P1: I don’t know if you should be bolding words, italicization for emphasis might be a better bet. But also, you could do without either!

    Once again, good job – I can’t wait to read the final copy!

    Happy editing,
    Farwa 🙂

  3. Tessa Sigi Avatar
    Tessa Sigi

    Hi Euna,

    Your title is so creative and drew me in! I think your blog post was really interesting. Here are a few suggestions to keep in mind while you edit:

    – Chemical compounds and elements generally do not need to be capitalized.

    – In-text citations with single authors do not need commas between the name and date. So it should look like this (Last name Year).

    – I think it would be really good if you have a figure, maybe explaining how the collision of tectonic plates leads to the exposure of rocks rich in phosphorus.

    Overall, great work! I can’t wait to read the final.

    Tessa

  4. Maya Kumar Avatar
    Maya Kumar

    Hi Euna

    Great job on your blog post! I found it to be a very interesting read!

    – I would make sure your use the DOI link from your journals to use in your references

    – I believe “phosphorus” should not be capitalized in a running sentence

    – P1S4: Perhaps moving this sentence further up in the paragraph will help with flow, this sentence also needs a citation

    – P4S2: add “%” after 20 and 35

    – P4: There are some in text citation missing here

    Overall, great job! Happy editing!

Leave a Reply