What are the hidden secrets of Killarney’s crystal-clear lakes?

Killarney Provincial Park (KPP) in south-eastern Ontario contains a complex ecological system of more than 50 lakes covering over 645 square kilometres (“Killarney Provincial Park,” n.d.). For years, KPP was the place to go to see crystal-clear lakes. Now this effect is much less common, and though some tourists may be sad, it is a very good thing for nature lovers. The reason behind the clear lakes was that everything inside them had died from rising pH levels. What caused the increase in pH? The simple answer is acid rain, but it’s much more complex than just that.

During the 1970s and 80s, acid rain was the environment’s most pressing issue, much like global warming or climate change right now (Grennfelt et al. 2020). Acid rain was mostly caused by the washouts of sulphur and nitrogen oxides. Coal-fired power stations, smelters (emitting SO₂), and car exhaust (emitting NO) are major factors that, when mixed with other chemicals in the environment, can produce corrosive substances (Singh and Agrawal 2008). According to Grennfelt et al. (2020), the reason acid rain is no longer talked about as much isn’t because it was swept under the rug to deal with more pressing issues, but actually because lots has been done in North America and Europe to combat it. 

During this time, the effects of acid rain were amplified in KPP for two reasons. The first reason is its proximity to the Sudbury sulphur plants. The second reason is KPP’s different rock compositions, which include a range of both igneous bedrock and calcium-rich sedimentary rocks (i.e., limestone). Different lakes fall in different catchments of this composition (Lanigan et al. 2025). The minerals that compose limestone and other carbonate-rich rocks chemically react with and neutralize acidity when acid rain enters a lake composed of limestone through weathering. This process increases the lake’s buffering capacity and helps prevent its pH from dropping. Though this leads to the erosion of the lake, it causes the pH to remain the same. When acid enters a lake composed of bedrock, this reaction does not occur, and the acid stays in the lake, decreasing the total pH. Bell, Acid, George and Nellie Lakes are examples of lakes composed of granite bedrock (a type of igneous rock) that were heavily affected by acid rain (Belzile et al. 2004).

References

Belzile, Nelson, Yu-Wei Chen, John M. Gunn, and Sushil S. Dixit. 2004. “Sediment Trace Metal Profiles in Lakes of Killarney Park, Canada: From Regional to Continental Influence.” Environmental Pollution 130 (2): 239–48. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2003.12.003. 

Grennfelt, Peringe, Anna Engleryd, Martin Forsius, Øystein Hov, Henning Rodhe, and Ellis Cowling. 2020. “Acid Rain and Air Pollution: 50 Years of Progress in Environmental Science and Policy.” Ambio 49 (4): 849–64. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13280-019-01244-4. 

“Killarney Provincial Park.” n.d. Accessed November 17, 2026. https://ontarioparks.capark/killarney. 

Lanigan, Courtney, Neal Michelutti, Andrew M. Paterson, Carsten Meyer-Jacob, Brigitte Simmatis, and John P. Smol. 2025. “Using Paleolimnology to Assess Long-Term Acidification and Recovery Trajectories in Lakes from Killarney Provincial Park and Sudbury (Ontario, Canada).” Journal of Paleolimnology 73 (3): 217–37. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10933-025-00356-0. 

Singh, Anita, and Madhoolika Agrawal. 2008. Acid Rain and Its Ecological Consequences. s.ca/park/killarney.

Comments

8 Responses to “What are the hidden secrets of Killarney’s crystal-clear lakes?”

  1. Maya Knight Avatar
    Maya Knight

    Hey iSci
    The first I had heard about this was during a canoe trip I took to Killarney this summer. My dad had told me that the last time he had been here, the now only slightly clear lakes used to be practically transparent. His friend had shown me in a book a graph that included each of the lakes in the area we were surrounded by and their relative range in pH over time. I was reminded of it again while learning about the methane cycle and how it contributes to acid rain. After being reminded, I started to consider what this means for climate change and concepts I have learned in Earth Science.
    Maya

  2. Aveline Desousa Avatar
    Aveline Desousa

    Hi Maya,

    This was a really interesting blog post! I have a few suggestions that I hope are helpful to your edits.

    I would put a comma in between the two sentences “During the 1970s and 80s, acid rain was the environment’s most pressing issue. Much like global warming or climate change right now,” this would help it flow better.

    You’re still a little bit under the word count, you could add a short conclusion just to summarize the main points of your blog

    Overall I thought this was super intriguing and well written! Best of luck with edits!

    Aveline

  3. Cheron Chung Avatar
    Cheron Chung

    Hey Maya,

    I really loved reading your blog post on Killarney National Park, it was very informative! I just have a few suggestions:
    – I think you may have a spelling error of Killarney in your title and first sentence
    – P1S1: remember to do your in-text citation in the Chicago style, not with the link
    – P2S1 & S2: You can combine these sentences to make it flow a bit better: “most pressing issue, much like global warming or climate change right now.”
    – P3S3 & S4: Again, you can combine these sentence for better flow
    – P3: You mention the rock composition of KPP includes limestone, but later say the minerals that compose limestone neutralize acidity when acid rain enters, preventing the pH from dropping too much. However, I thought the reason for KPP’s lakes being clear was because the acid stays in the lake, killing the organisms inside.
    – This is a personal preference, but maybe you can add a picture showing the before and after of the lakes, just to provide some visual balance to the article.

    Happy editing!
    Cheron

    1. Maya Knight Avatar
      Maya Knight

      I appreciate your help. I edited the spelling in P2S1 & S2, and P3S3 & S4. I will change my in-text citations to author-date and add a figure or image. I will also clarify that in P3 I was referring to why only the lakes composed of bedrock had drastic pH changes and not the ones composed of limestone.

  4. Audrey Thompson Avatar
    Audrey Thompson

    Hi Maya!

    This was a very interesting blog post, I enjoyed reading it. I have a couple of suggestions that may help strengthen your overall post:

    – Your first source, (Www.Ontarioparks.Ca, n.d.) looks off, is the Www. needed? I would just double check that this is a reliable source and that it is cited correctly.

    – I found when reading your introductory pargraph I had to re read it to fully understand it. Maybe reading it aloud and making edits so it flows better would be useful.

    – In P2 you write (emitting SO2) making the 2 a subscript would make this cleaner.

    – Adding a conclusion that summarizing your blog more concisely and does not bring in new information would help bring the ending back to KPP.

  5. Hassan Rasheed Avatar
    Hassan Rasheed

    Hi Maya,
    Great post! I liked how you connected Killarney’s clear lakes to acid rain and the rock composition of each lake. I just have a few suggestions:

    P1S4–5: You mention that the lakes died from “rising pH levels” and ask what caused “the increase in pH.” Acid rain actually lowers a lake’s pH, since the water becomes more acidic. Changing this to “falling pH” or “increased acidity” would make it match what you explain in P3.

    Figure suggestion: Consider adding a graph comparing pH over time in a bedrock lake (like George Lake) and a limestone lake. This would show readers why only some lakes were affected. Lanigan et al. (2025) might have data you could use.

    References: The Singh and Agrawal (2008) entry seems incomplete. It’s missing the journal name and has part of a URL at the end.

    Excited to see the final version. Good luck!
    Hassan

  6. Aaron Ling Avatar
    Aaron Ling

    Hey Maya!

    I thought that this was a really fascinating, especially how the conditions of a lake may be damaged even if it looks beautiful in our eyes. The only thing that I would suggest would be a couple figures. Maybe you could add a before and after image of the lake, or how the different biogeochemical processes that affect the states of the lake. Other than that it’s great!

    Good Luck
    Aaron

  7. Saanvi Praveen Avatar
    Saanvi Praveen

    Hey Maya,

    Great job on your post! It was very informative to read.
    Here are a few pieces of feedback:

    – P1S1: I recommend rephrasing the sentence to “For years, KPP was the go-to place for crystal-clear lakes, however, this effect is much less common..” For better flow of the sentence.

    – P2S3: is a bit confusing to understand; I would recommend either rephrasing the sentence or breaking it into two sentences.

    – I would also recommend adding a figure for visual representation of either the lake itself or the different rock compositions you mentioned.

    – Your last citation does not seem to have a link, make sure that it has a clear link to the website.

    I look forward to reading your final draft!
    Saanvi

Leave a Reply