No matter how you stack it, it’s poop: manure storage options for limiting greenhouse gases

We’ve all been there – faced with a pile of manure that we just don’t know how to store. What shape and conditions will cause the least emissions while still allowing it to stay intact? Ok, so maybe we haven’t all been there, but these are still important considerations – and questions that can be answered with insights from agricultural science, material behaviour, and soft matter physics.

Of the substantial greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions produced by the agricultural industry, manure management contributes approximately 2-3% in the form of methane and 7-10% in the form of nitrous oxide (Li et al. 2025). A 2020 study from Zhu et al. looked at emissions from different types of animal manures, finding highest methane levels from dairy cattle manure and highest nitrous oxide levels from beef cattle manure.

Manure stack height has been shown to affect the GHG emissions generated (Dong et al. 2011). In a 2011 paper from Dong et al., manure stacks of 10, 20, and 40 centimetres in height were monitored for carbon dioxide, nitrous oxide, and methane emissions. Alongside emissions, this study analyzed physical and chemical properties like volatile solids, dry matter, and nitrogen and carbon content. Ultimately, Dong et al. found that methane emissions did not vary significantly with stack height, while carbon dioxide and nitrous oxide emissions were higher in shorter stacks. However, when accounting for the global warming potential of these gases, 20-centimetre stacks produced the lowest overall GHG emissions.

The work from Li et al. and Zhu et al. were conducted in lab settings to limit confounding variables, but as a result, may lack some practicality. In both studies, manure was placed in Plexi-glass cylinders for testing, but in the real world, how will it hold up? Manure can be modelled based on its moisture content to analyze flowability and deformation, similar to problems in soft-matter physics (You et al. 2026). In their study, You et al. examined two types of manure-derived fertilizers with different moisture contents, using physical experiments and discrete element modelling to investigate their flowability. They found that moisture content influenced the angle of repose and, subsequently, its ability to maintain a pile. While their research focused on fertilizer application rather than storage, these findings provide a starting point for understanding how manure piles maintain their structure.

Though these three aspects of manure properties may seem unrelated, they are starting points in understanding how we can balance structural stability with reducing GHG emissions. More research is certainly needed to understand how these variables interact under real-world conditions, but soft matter physics has proven to offer useful perspectives in making manure management both more practical and more sustainable.

Works Cited

Dong, Hongmin, Zhiping Zhu, Zhongkai Zhou, Hongwei Xin, and Yongxing Chen. 2011. “Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Swine Manure Stored at Different Stack Heights.” Animal Feed Science and Technology, Special Issue: Greenhouse Gases in Animal Agriculture – Finding a Balance between Food and Emissions, vols. 166–167 (June): 557–61. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anifeedsci.2011.04.039.

Li, Lidong, Tala Awada, Yeyin Shi, Virginia L. Jin, and Michael Kaiser. 2025. “Global Greenhouse Gas Emissions From Agriculture: Pathways to Sustainable Reductions.” Global Change Biology 31 (1): e70015. https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.70015.

You, Jia, Pingfan Wu, Haochen Shao, Lujia Han, and Guangqun Huang. 2026. “Discrete Element Simulation Calibration and Flowability Study of Organic Manure with Different Moisture Contents.” Agriculture 16 (5): 508. https://doi.org/10.3390/agriculture16050508.

Zhu, Zhiping, Lulu Li, Hongmin Dong, and Yue Wang. 2020. “Ammonia and Greenhouse Gas Emissions of Different Types of Livestock and Poultry Manure During Storage.” Transactions of the ASABE 63 (6): 1723–33. https://doi.org/10.13031/trans.14079.

Comments

8 Responses to “No matter how you stack it, it’s poop: manure storage options for limiting greenhouse gases”

  1. Keira Sponagle Avatar
    Keira Sponagle

    Hello iSci!
    Our climate change group has focused on the agricultural industry’s contributions to climate change and that is what inspired this post. With my interest in soft matter physics, I wanted to see if there was a way to model the optimal shape of a manure pile as well, so I tried to combine the two – manure pile emissions and shape. Though this is a bit of a random blog post, I hope you find it interesting! I am looking forward to your feedback – especially on potentially incorporating a figure and improving the post’s logical flow.

    Thank you,
    Keira

  2. Ethan Yoon Avatar
    Ethan Yoon

    Hello, Keira! What an amazing and awesome blog post, and your writing style was so captivating and kept me reading! I just have a couple of comments:
    1. Paragraph 2, sentence 2: Make sure you add a “the” in front of “highest” both times!
    2. Paragraph 4, sentence 5: I think it would be great if you could define the angle of repose, as it isn’t a common term!
    3. One question that came up to me was why manure needed to stay intact. Does manure need to be in its original form or forms to act as an effective fertilizer? Can anything be done to secure it in a different form (e.g. freeze-dried manure)?

    Once again, this was a wonderful blog post, and I can’t wait to read the final version. 🙂

    – Ethan

  3. Aanya Patel Avatar
    Aanya Patel

    Hey Keira!

    Really captivating title! Overall, I really liked your blog, it was a different topic I never knew about before. I thought it was unique from how you connect multiple studies and manure management, greenhouse gas emissions, and soft matter physics. I would like to give some recommendations on how you could add onto it.

    I really think your post could benefit from some sort of figure to help readers visualize what you are speaking about. For example it could really help readers understand P4, specifically Li et al. and Dong et al.lab set-up to help understand the experimental design for the manure-derived fertilizers with different moisture contents to investigate their flowability.

    Also I was hoping you could expand on the significance of the 20-centimetre stack height, and could be explained further. I more so wanted an explanation why this height produced the lowest overall emissions, despite you saying carbon dioxide and nitrous oxide emissions were higher in shorter stacks (and of the three values 10 cm, 20 cm, and 40 cm I would say that 20 cm is still relatively small).

    Lastly, I know you mention that the three aspects of manure properties may seem unrelated; I just wish you flowed from P3 into P4 a bit better with some sort of clear transition or relation as you did from P2 to P3. Maybe preface with why the study you start talking about relates to manure stack height or links into your next point in P4 as the shift feels abrupt and I don’t know what you are necessarily talking about until I finish reading the whole paragraph.

    Other than that, cool topic and I can’t wait to read your final draft!

    -Aanya

  4. Luca Madriz-Zikic Avatar
    Luca Madriz-Zikic

    Hi Keira,

    Fun post. I thought your walkthrough of the Dong et al. design is clear and your thoughts are well organized throughout the post.

    Some comments/suggestions:

    – Li et al. (2025) is not a lab study. It analyzes global FAO emissions data, so the claim that both Li et al. and Dong et al. placed manure in cylinders is incorrect. The study you’re likely thinking of is Zhu et al. (2020), which measured emissions in lab chambers.
    – “approximately 2-3% in the form of methane and 7-10% in the form of nitrous oxide” doesn’t say what it is a percentage of (agricultural emissions? total emissions?
    – The Dong et al. abstract reports that shorter stacks had higher CO2 and N2O but lower methane, not that methane didn’t vary. If the results section shows the methane difference wasn’t significant, state it that way.
    – You et al. studied fertilizer flowability to support spreading equipment design, and none of the three studies links pile stability to emissions. “Has proven to offer useful perspectives” would be more accurate as “may offer,”.
    – “The work from Li et al. and Dong et al. were” should be “was.”
    – “its ability to maintain a pile” doesn’t clearly say what “its” refers to.

    Once again, solid post.
    Best of luck with the edits,
    Luca

  5. Audrey Ferris Avatar
    Audrey Ferris

    Hi Keira!

    This was a really interesting blog post with a great hook! A few comments I have for you are the following:
    -In P2, you mention that dairy cattle emit more methane, whereas beef cattle emit more nitrous oxide. Consider adding a brief explanation as to why this is!
    – I think you should expand on what an angle of repose is and how this changes with differences in manure piles, coming from someone who doesn’t know much about soft-matter physics!
    – I like how you applied studies that weren’t exactly studying manure piles to speculate solutions for this problem! I thought that was very insightful!

    Overall, this was a great post, and I look forward to reading the final edits!!
    – Audrey

  6. Gavin Lee Avatar
    Gavin Lee

    Great post Keira! I think most people know that climate change is multi-faceted but this is certainly not a well-known facet, and I thought it was super interesting. Some minor notes:
    – The sentence “They found that moisture content influenced the angle of repose and, subsequently, its ability to maintain a pile” might be a little clearer if you wrote “…the manure’s ability to maintain a pile”. You don’t actually mention manure in the previous two sentences so this might clarify that the fertilizer makes the manure more or less pile-able.
    – I’m not sure we’d really want an image figure for this (: but are there any graphs for the You et al. study? It might make your point a little bit more clear with regards to the fertilizer influencing manure stack height.
    – Your point at the start of the 4th paragraph is a bit unclear. Do you meant that the first two studies don’t have a way of influencing stack height (which you address with the You et al. study), or that the emissions probably vary a lot more in the real world?

    This was so fun to read, I know that some of my points are a little bit vague but that’s mostly because the post was really good.
    Good luck editing!
    – Gavin

  7. Asyah Zalmai Avatar
    Asyah Zalmai

    Hi Kiera,

    I really enjoyed reading your blog post! I found your topic super interesting, the way you linked manure storage to greenhouse gas emissions and soft matter physics was awesome. Here are some suggestions:

    1. in P2, you mentioned methane and nitrous oxide emissions. I think it would be beneficial to quickly explain why these gases contribute to climate change and what aspects of them causes this.

    2. in P3, you mentioned manure stack heights and the ways they effect greenhouse gas emissions. Here is where you could add a figure explaining the three stack heights and their emissions. This would help readers understand the results of the study without having to imagine everything on their own.

    3. in P4, you mentioned the angle of repose. Its important to explain what this is first and then follow it by talking about how it affects the ability of manure to maintain its shape when stored in piles.

    Overall, I found this a very interesting read! I really like how you connected different scientific aspects to a real world issue. Goodluck with you final post, looking forward to it!

    – Asyah

  8. Rasmus Howson Creutzberg Avatar
    Rasmus Howson Creutzberg

    Hi Kiera!

    Overall loved everything, the topic the flow, and the “structure” 🙂 I always love to read agriculture related posts especially when they involve physics and real practical attempts at limiting GHG emissions by investigating small easily implementable changes like pile height. While I was reading your post it flew by, you explained everything clearly, with very easily followable organisation and logic.

    You have two fantastic opportunities to add a figure, there are the findings on pile height where even a results table would fit right in and make the findings clear at a glance. The second fantastic opportunity is on your discussion of the soft-matter physics modeling of a manure pile, a figure explaining angle of repose in this context and maybe how moisture content actually affected the angle, as you touch on it but do not explicitly tell us how it affects the angle of repose, which is a fantastic spot to add a nice figure.

    In the end I have no other notes, your hook and title are fun exciting intruding and relevant to your subject matter, along with your unique straightforward prose makes it almost to easy to read! I hope you post another blogpost on this topic because i would absolutely love to read it!

    Happy editing!

    Rasmus

Leave a Reply