The Problem with Problem Solving

The desire to solve problems and understand what is going on around us is a fundamental part of the human experience. People partake in problem solving every day, whether that be trying to figure out why the toaster will not release the toast or how to leverage artificial intelligence to tackle antibiotic resistance (Catacutan et al. 2025). Scientists are simply people who problem solve for a living using a more systematic approach. Across disciplines, the number of problems scientists are trying to solve are innumerable, however a proportion of research focuses on fixing problems instead of avoiding causing them.

The majority of these band-aid solutions are in the realm of climate change research. Since the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change announced the 1.5°C global temperature increase limit, the pressure to solve climate change has intensified (IPCC 2018; Schipper et al. 2021). Governments, institutions and the media want actionable information that can be summarized in one sentence and easily digested by the public (Schipper et al. 2021). Inevitably, this leads to oversimplifications and a push for solution-facing articles.

Condie et al. (2021) evaluated the efficiency of various interventions in mitigating the effects of climate change on the Great Barrier Reef. The article concluded that interventions which protected coral reefs from predation and solar radiation where most effective and could delay the reefs collapse by a few decades. These findings were further reported by newspapers with the flashy titles (Readfearn 2021). The article did not, however, discuss the underlying causes coral reef decline.

Select climate change research is also guilty of masking the symptoms of the issues rather than solving them. Dong et al. (2026) correlated genetically engineered (GE) crop adoption with climate, crop yield and harvested area data and determined that GE crops improved average yields in the face of extreme weather conditions. While GE crops’ potential benefits should not be overlooked, Dong et al. (2026) failed to address the core problems of climate change stress on the agricultural sector. As climate change accelerates, should all crops be replaced with their GE-counterparts? While rhetorical, this question highlights the workaround perspective most solution-focused research takes. 

Articles where researchers look to repair instead of prevent damage exist across disciplines. Porrello et al. (2011) experimentally found that neonatal mice hearts can regenerate tissue after a heart attack. Varjani et al. (2020) determined that Pseudomonas aeruginosa can biodegrade petroleum hydrocarbons in soil. While both publications beneficially contribute to the literature in their respective fields, neither address the root problem of preventing heart attacks or agricultural land pollution, respectively.

On the flip side, some problems are created in order to research specific processes. To investigate the role of nonrapid eye movement (NREM) sleep in restorative brain functions, Driessen et al. (2026) sleep-deprived mice. NREM sleep is synchronous periods of spiking activity (on periods) and silence (off periods) in cortical neurons (Driessen at al. 2026; Vyazovskiy et al. 2009). By inducing sleep deprivation, then optogenetically stimulating the cortex to mimic NREM on/off periods during wake, the authors found that sleep pressure was relieved (Driessen at al. 2026). While sleep deprivation is arguably required to improve our understanding of sleep mechanisms, the article did fix a problem the authors caused. 

This post is neither for nor against solution-focused research; it simply wishes to point out that there exists research where solving problems is a greater focus that trying to avoid causing them.    

References

Catacutan, Denise B., Vian Tran, Autumn Arnold, et al. 2025. “Discovery and Artificial Intelligence-Guided Mechanistic Elucidation of a Narrow-Spectrum Antibiotic.” Nature Microbiology 10 (11): 2808–22. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41564-025-02142-0.

Condie, Scott A., Kenneth R. N. Anthony, Russ C. Babcock, et al. 2021. “Large-Scale Interventions May Delay Decline of the Great Barrier Reef.” Royal Society Open Science 8 (4): 201296. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.201296.

Dong, Caroline Yifan, Chengcheng J. Fei, Bruce A. McCarl, David Zilberman, and Xingguo Wang. 2026. “Genetically Engineered Crop Adoption Support Yields and Cultivation under Climate Change.” Nature Climate Change 16 (10): 1214–21. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41558-026-02737-3.

Driessen, Kort, Fabio Squarcio, Giulio Tononi, and Chiara Cirelli. 2026. “Induction of Cortical on/off Periods in Awake Mice Fulfills Sleep Functions.” Nature Neuroscience 29 (8): 1954–65. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41593-026-02318-9.

Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). 2018. Global Warming of 1.5°C: Summary for Policymakers. https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/sites/2/2022/06/SPM_version_report_LR.pdf.

Porrello, Enzo R., Ahmed I. Mahmoud, Emma Simpson, et al. 2011. “Transient Regenerative Potential of the Neonatal Mouse Heart.” Science 331 (6020): 1078–80. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1200708.

Readfearn, Graham. 2021. “‘Life Support’ Measures Could Buy Great Barrier Reef Another Two Decades, Study Finds.” Environment. The Guardian, April 28. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/apr/29/life-support-measures-could-buy-great-barrier-reef-another-two-decades-study-finds.

Schipper, E. Lisa F., Navroz K. Dubash, and Yacob Mulugetta. 2021. “Climate Change Research and the Search for Solutions: Rethinking Interdisciplinarity.” Climatic Change 168 (3): 18. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-021-03237-3.

Varjani, Sunita, and Vivek N. Upasani. 2020. “Soil Microcosm Study for Bioremediation by a Crude Oil Degrading Pseudomonas Aeruginosa NCIM 5514.” Journal of Environmental Engineering 146 (5): 04020027. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)EE.1943-7870.0001687.

Vyazovskiy, Vladyslav V., Umberto Olcese, Yaniv M. Lazimy, et al. 2009. “Cortical Firing and Sleep Homeostasis.” Neuron 63 (6): 865–78. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2009.08.024.

Comments

7 Responses to “The Problem with Problem Solving”

  1. Chloe Logan Avatar
    Chloe Logan

    Hello iSci!

    In the most recent Climate Change lecture, we discussed how trying to fix the problem of human development (in relation to climate change) often creates more problems that end up harming the climate more than helping. This got me thinking of a neuroscience article I read a few months prior about how researchers optogenetically stimulated mice brains to help them recover from sleep deprevation (which they induced). Does a lot of scientific work involve creating issues then solving them to figure out how stuff works? Are more articles about fixing problems instead of avoiding causing them? I found this potential trend quite interesting, and it sparked my idea for this blog post. In particular, I would appreciate some feedback on overall clarity of my argument and if you think more examples (with less details in each because of word count) are needed.

    Thank you in advance for the comments,

    Chloe

  2. Ethan Yoon Avatar
    Ethan Yoon

    Hey, Chloe! Awesome work on your blog post, and it’s quite funny and eye-opening that we as scientists might be doing so much that we need to create problems just to solve. I just have a couple of suggestions:

    1. Paragraph 1, sentence 1: Consider adding a comma before the quotation, i.e. “Scott Adams wrote, ‘Engineers…”.
    2. Paragraph 1, sentence 4: I’m very interested in that claim. Do you have a source you can use to back up the increasing anthropogenicity of problems? It would be an awesome read!
    3. A figure (such as one backing up the above claim, or a collage of papers you believe fall into the trap of solving problems they created) would be appreciated!
    4. This is more general, but where do you believe you draw the line between problem-solving for the sake of problem-solving and simple hypothesis testing? In the case of Driessen et al., there is an argument to be made about how the problem had to be artificially caused for it to be solved, or how the man-made solution to this man-made problem still has lasting positive consequences for general human and animal sleep (making it worth it in a sense).

    That’s all I have to say. Once again, awesome and well thought-out blog post, and I can’t wait to read the final version! 🙂

    – Ethan

    1. Chloe Logan Avatar
      Chloe Logan

      Hi Ethan,

      Thank you so much for your comment!

      To address your first suggestion, I decided to cut the quote so it’s no longer applicable, but I appreciate the grammar tips (I normally need them). I see what you mean in your second suggestion that the sentence feels like it is missing a citation; however, I used this part to frame my argument so there is not really a specific source where I got the info from (it’s the collection of papers I cite below). I think I tried to make my writing too “fancy” so I reworded things a bit. Hopefully the sentence sounds more thesis-like now! Personal preference, but I don’t feel like a figure is needed since I normally only include them to help me explain a complex process or if I think it would contribute to my argument (and I can’t find one that does). I LOVE your last suggestions and I wish I had the word count to talk more about it. I made some edits to try make me seem more impartial; I don’t think this tactic is necessarily good or bad in all contexts it’s just a pattern I’ve noticed.

      Thanks again for your feedback. So glad you enjoyed the post 🙂

      Chloe

  3. Heer Upadhyay Avatar
    Heer Upadhyay

    Hi Chloe,
    Wow, your blog post topic is super fascinating and thought provoking! I never really thought of us creating our own problems as scientists but it makes so much sense!

    My one suggestion is, if word count permits, perhaps you can make a larger conclusion paragraph to tie everything together. I do like your two points on climate change and then neuroscience, but it would be nice if at the end, both of them could be brought together and maybe discuss the implications, and what can be done moving forward.

    Overall awesome blog post and happy editing!
    Heer

    1. Chloe Logan Avatar
      Chloe Logan

      Hi Heer,

      Thank you so much for your feedback, it’s always appreciated 🙂

      Unfortunately, I am very tight on word count but I did change my conclusion to wrap things up a bit better (implications wouldn’t fit without making a whole new paragraph). I do agree that it wasn’t the best the first time around thought.

      Chloe

  4. Brand Hu Avatar
    Brand Hu

    Hi Chloe,

    Great post! Your questioning of whether or not people are creating unnecessary problems in hopes of finding solutions is definitely an interesting perspective. With that said here is some feedback.

    In paragraph 1, the overall opening feels unsupported and broad “an increasing proportion have anthropogenic sources” so perhaps reframing your overall argument as more of a question (ex. like you mentioned in your comment, Are more articles about fixing problems instead of avoiding causing them?) could work better

    The two examples you provided are also fundamentally different kinds of problems: climate change is an unintended problem where research offer treatment for symptoms, while the sleep study on mice is deliberately induced sleep deprivation as a direct method to test a mechanism. That makes the “avoid causing problems” conclusion hard to apply to both. For climate it’s a reasonable call to prevent harm at the source, but for the sleep study, avoiding the problem would mean not running the experiment at all.

    Rather than expanding the range of examples, I’d focus on a more specific scope/pattern and choose distinct examples that clearly fits it. For example, you could perhaps re-pivot the mice study to explore how scientists deliberately create problems to understand how things work

    Good luck on your final draft and I hope you have fun!

    Best,
    Brand

    1. Chloe Logan Avatar
      Chloe Logan

      Hi Brand,

      Thank you so much for all of your comments!

      I completely understand your hesitation with the first paragraph. My argument wasn’t very clear and I think in my effort to make my writing sound good I lost what I was trying to say. I re-worded almost the entire thing and hopefully made it easier to understand. I agree with your second and third suggestions that, at first glance, the neuroscience and climate change papers don’t seem like they “fit” together well and the argument gets lost. After changing the intro and adding in three more examples, I hope you will see my vision and how the argument applies to them all (I also stated the discrepancy you mentioned between creating problems intentionally and not-intentionally).

      Thanks again for your insightful feedback 🙂

      Chloe