Is it Blue and Black or White and Gold?

In 2015, a single photo of a dress (see Figure 1) seemed to divide the entire internet. Some people saw the dress as blue and black, while others saw white and gold. Despite staring at the same image, neither side could understand how anyone could see it differently. What seemed like a bizarre debate soon became a scientific mystery. How can two people look at the exact same image and interpret it completely differently? 

Figure 1. The viral photograph of the dress that sparked widespread debate in 2015 due to the difference in colour perception (Wikipedia 2021).

Colour is not an inherent property of an object, but rather the result of how your brain interprets light. When light hits an object, certain wavelengths are absorbed while others are reflected. These reflected wavelengths enter your eyes and contribute to the colour we perceive. The molecular structure of an object determines which wavelengths it absorbs and reflects, meaning that different materials interact with light differently (Cianci 2023). The reflected light ultimately is what your brain interprets as colour.

Once reflected light enters the eye, it reaches a layer at the back of the human eye called the retina. The retina is where two types of photoreceptor cells, rods and cones, are located. These cells convert incoming light into electrical signals that are sent to the brain for processing. Rods are responsible for vision in dim lighting and help you distinguish between light and dark, while cones allow you to perceive colour in lighter conditions. Humans generally have three types of cone cells, each sensitive to different ranges of light wavelengths: short, medium and long wavelengths, which ultimately correspond to blue, green and red (see Figure 2). Together these cones send combined information to the brain allowing you to identify millions of different colours. The brain then processes these signals through the central nervous system, transforming the information detected by your eyes into the colours we consciously experience (Bevil R 2021). 

Figure 2. The visible spectrum of electromagnetic radiation, illustrating the range of wavelengths detectable by the human eye (approximately 380-780 nm). Shorter wavelengths at 445 nanometres (nm) are correlated to the S cones which detect blue light. Medium wavelengths at 535 nm are related to the M cones and detect green light. Lastly, long wavelengths at 565 nm are connected to L cones and can interpret red light. When more than one of these cones are activated, we see various colours (Letstalkscience.Ca 2019).

However, colour perception is influenced by more than just the wavelength detected by your eyes. Several factors, including surrounding colours, lighting conditions, brightness and visual context, can influence how your brain interprets incoming light (Nassau 2006). One important process involved is known as colour constancy, which allows you to recognize an object’s colour even when the lighting around it changes. For example, a white shirt would normally seem white, whether it is seen under bright sunlight or artificial lighting, despite the light reflected into your eyes being different as illumination changes. This happens because the brain tries to account for the surrounding illumination and adjust its interpretation of the incoming reflected wavelengths. When illumination conditions are unclear, the brain may make different assumptions about the environment an object is in, causing people to perceive the same image differently (Hurlbert 2007). 

So whether you see black and blue or white and gold, it is simply a difference in the way your brain interprets colour based on lighting. Since the original photo is overexposed, the lighting is unclear leaving your brain to fill in the uncertainty to distinguish the colour.  Some people assume the dress is in a bluish shadow and mentally subtract the blue illumination, causing the dress to appear white and gold. Others assume it is under warmer, artificial lighting leading them to perceive the dress as blue and black (Devitt 2017). This demonstrates how your brain uses colour constancy to compensate for illumination, allowing objects to appear relatively consistent in colour even with changing lighting conditions. Despite the science behind our perception, the question remains: do you see white and gold, or blue and black?

References

Bevil R, Conway. 2021. “Colors.” Current Biology 31 (16): R982–83. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2021.06.072.

Christoph, Witzel, O. Regan J. Kevin, and Sabrina Hansmann-Roth. 2017. “The Dress and Individual Differences in the Perception of Surface Properties.” Individual Differences as a Window into the Structure and Function of the Visual System 141 (December): 76–94. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.visres.2017.07.015.

Cianci, Lisa. 2023. “Why Are Things Different Colours?” Pressbooks.Pub, RMIT Open Press, February 23. https://rmit.pressbooks.pub/colourtheory1/chapter/why-are-things-different-colours/.

Datacolor. 2020. “The Science of How We See Color.” September 30. https://www.datacolor.com/business-solutions/blog/why-we-cant-agree-color-perception/.

Devitt, James. 2017. “Why Did We See ‘The Dress’ Differently? The Answer Lies in the Shadows, Neuroscience Research Finds.” Www.Nyu.Edu, April 7. https://www.nyu.edu/about/news-publications/news/2017/april/why-did-we-see-_the-dress-differently–the-answer-lies-in-the-sh.html.

Hurlbert, Anya. 2007. “Colour Constancy.” Current Biology 17 (21): R906–7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2007.08.022.

Letstalkscience.Ca. 2019. “How Do We See Colour? – Let’s Talk Science.” July 23. https://letstalkscience.ca/educational-resources/stem-explained/how-do-we-see-colour.

Lewis, Tanya. 2015. “Science of ‘The Dress’: Why We Confuse White & Gold With Blue & Black.” Livescience.Com, Live Science, May 14. https://www.livescience.com/50842-dress-debate-color-perception.html.

Lifocolor.De. 2025. “How Colours Are Created and Why We See Them Differently.” June 2. https://www.lifocolor.de/en/news-events/why-people-perceive-colours-differently/.

Nassau, Kurt. 2006. “Color | Definition, Perception, Types, & Facts.” In Encyclopædia Britannica. June 22. https://www.britannica.com/science/color.

Sherman, Bonnie S. 2013. “Perception of Brightness and Contrast.” In Research Starters. EBSCO. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/religion-and-philosophy/perception-brightness-and-contrast/.

Wikipedia. 2021. “The Dress.” Wikipedia, April 15. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_dress.

Comments

5 Responses to “Is it Blue and Black or White and Gold?”

  1. Zahra Imthiyas Avatar
    Zahra Imthiyas

    Hey Isci!

    I chose to write my post about the viral dress because I remember being fascinated by this debate growing up and thought it was finally time to cure the curiosity.

    This topic connects to iSci through both chemistry and psychology. In chemistry, we learned about how different wavelengths of light are absorbed and reflected. In psychology, we explored the central nervous system and how our eyes detect visual information, which is then transmitted to the brain for processing and interpretation.

    Bringing these concepts together allowed me to understand how something as simple as looking at a photograph involves several interconnected scientific processes

    I hope you enjoy reading! Feel free to leave me any suggestions.

    Zahra Imthiyas

  2. Alexandra Johnson Avatar
    Alexandra Johnson

    Hi Zahra,

    Very interesting blog post! I really enjoyed reading about the science behind human colour perception. Here are a few suggestions as you move onto the editing phase:

    – In Paragraph 4, I found sentence 4 confusing to read, so you could change it to something like: “For example, a white shirt would still seem white under many different lighting conditions, whether it is bright sunlight or artificial lighting. This white colour is seen as consistent despite the light reflected into your eyes being different as illumination changes.”

    – A few of your sources are from websites that might not be the most credible, so if it’s possible to find peer reviewed articles/sources to replace them that would strengthen the blog post! (Specifically Letstalkscience.Ca. 2019 and Lifocolor.De. 2025. )

    – Generally, it’s good practice to not introduce new information in your conclusion. This could be easily fixed by separating the last paragraph into two right after the (Devitt 2017) citation.

    Overall, it was a very well written blog post! Good luck editing,

    – Alexandra 🙂

  3. Swetha Subramanian Avatar
    Swetha Subramanian

    Hi Zahra,

    This is such an interesting topic to write about and I really like how you tied a viral internet post to grounded science. Some suggestions I have for you are:

    – You can rewrite P4S4 to be something like: “White shirts, for instance, would normally appear white, whether seen in bright sunlight or artificial lighting, regardless of how the light reflects into your eyes.”
    – In P3S5, you can remove the word “ultimately”
    – In P5S3, the phrase “mentally subtract” is a bit awkward. You can change it to something like: “subconsciously eliminate the blue illumination”

    Overall, great work and happy editing!

    Best,
    Swetha S

  4. Hala El-Barghouthi Avatar
    Hala El-Barghouthi

    Hi Zahra! Amazing blog post, I love how you brought back such a nostalgic controversial debate. I only believe it to be blue and black :).
    One suggestion:
    I think you should include a transition between paragraphs 2 and 3, you move from explaining how objects absorb and reflect light to how our eyes process that light and I feel like adding a little connection sentence between these two would make a smooth transition would be a more seamless read.

    Overall amazing blog post!!!

    Happy editing!
    Hala

  5. Stephanie Chan Avatar
    Stephanie Chan

    Hi Zarah! I remember this debate when the image went viral many years ago. It was super interesting to learn about the reason why it went so viral on a scientific level. I have a suggestion.

    -P3: This was really well written but I think it would be beneficial if you didn’t cite only once at the end of the paragraph. If you could find another source that also talks about what happens in the eye and how its related in how we interpret colour it would be beneficial. You could even cite the same source twice in the same paragraph. This would make it more clear which pieces of information is supported by a source.

    Overall, I think you did a great job! Looking forward to the final draft.
    Stephanie

Leave a Reply