Where Did the Semester Go?

If you were to ask your first year self how long the first semester felt, many would say it felt like a lifetime and fast forward now to third year and fall semester was over in a blink of an eye. The clocks didn’t change but something in the brain did, and the explanation for what changed is not completely solidified.

The Brain’s clock

Putting a semester into a lab as a unit of time is not possible. So researchers measure on a scale they can actually control such as seconds. 

Figure 1 demonstrates an experiment where young and older adults were trained to reproduce intervals of 8 and 21 seconds, and then were tested for two hours with no feedback. Over the recorded session, the older group drifted steadily, producing intervals longer than the target by the final group. The younger group barely moved (Malapani et al. 1998; Rakitin et al. 1998).

Figure 1. Reproduced time for 8-s and 21-s targets across four 30-minute blocks in young (19–28, n = 7) and aged (67–90, n = 12) participants. Data from Malapani et al. (1998) and Rakitin et al. (1998), as presented in Turgeon, Lustig, and Meck (2016). 

Producing a longer interval correlates to the clock running slow. More simply, fewer internal ticks means you need more real seconds to reach what feels like 21, creating an overshoot. A review by Turgeon, Lustig, and Meck (2016) links this to dopamine. The review explains this is due to striatal dopamine depleting during sustained mental effort, and also notes that the cortico-striatal circuits supporting our sense of time are vulnerable to age-related decline (Bäckman et al. 2010; Turgeon, Lustig, and Meck 2016). This causes a perceived speed up of the world while the internal clock slows down. Across ages 19 to 98, unpaced tapping rates become both slower and more variable with age (Turgeon and Wing 2012). 

Except that might not be the clock at all

A timing study done with a sample size of 647 people found timing performance tracked general cognitive scores. Control for those scores and the relationship with age vanishes (Bartholomew, Meck, and Cirulli 2015). The clock we all like to blame might be completely fine, but the attention and working memory may just be doing the job worse (Lustig and Meck 2001).

This can be applied even to our perception of time from just our first year. First year needed constant attention, whether it went from navigating a new campus to even trying out different techniques in the lab. By third year the lectures, walks to class and the routine you have made the last two years are so ingrained you don’t think twice about it.

The gap that hasn’t been closed

Everything that was talked about above happens in mere seconds and minutes. We do not realize the time passed until we think retrospectively (Janssen, Naka, and Friedman 2013). A semester occurs over the span of months, and you only notice how fast it has passed when it is almost done. Researchers believe the feeling of time passing by faster the more you age applies mostly to looking back on the years passed, and that timing on that scale depends heavily on different neural systems (Wittmann and Lehnhoff 2005; Turgeon, Lustig, and Meck 2016).

There is a measurable mechanism that operates on seconds and a vivid experience operating on months but the bridge between these two spans of time doesn’t yet exist. As much as the dopamine connection seems biologically plausible it isn’t the whole story.

A plausible story and an actual common feeling are not the same as a plausible explanation. Sometimes the honest answer is that we do not currently know and are still guessing about how the semester passed by so fast. It serves as a reminder to be present everyday because everything will pass by fast.

References

Bäckman, Lars, Ulman Lindenberger, Shu-Chen Li, and Lars Nyberg. 2010. “Linking Cognitive Aging to Alterations in Dopamine Neurotransmitter Functioning: Recent Data and Future Avenues.” Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews 34 (5): 670–677. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2009.12.008.

Bartholomew, Aaron J., Warren H. Meck, and Elizabeth T. Cirulli. 2015. “Analysis of Genetic and Non-Genetic Factors Influencing Timing and Time Perception.” PLoS ONE 10 (12): e0143873. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0143873.

Janssen, Steve M. J., Makiko Naka, and William J. Friedman. 2013. “Why Does Life Appear to Speed Up as People Get Older?” Time & Society 22 (2): 274–290. https://doi.org/10.1177/0961463X13478052.

Lustig, Cindy, and Warren H. Meck. 2001. “Paying Attention to Time as One Gets Older.” Psychological Science 12 (6): 478–484. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9280.00389.

Malapani, Chara, Brian Rakitin, Richard Levy, Warren H. Meck, Bernard Deweer, Bruno Dubois, and John Gibbon. 1998. “Coupled Temporal Memories in Parkinson’s Disease: A Dopamine-Related Dysfunction.” Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 10 (3): 316–331. https://doi.org/10.1162/089892998562762.

Rakitin, Brian C., John Gibbon, Trevor B. Penney, Chara Malapani, Sean C. Hinton, and Warren H. Meck. 1998. “Scalar Expectancy Theory and Peak-Interval Timing in Humans.” Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes 24 (1): 15–33. https://doi.org/10.1037/0097-7403.24.1.15.

Turgeon, Martine, and Alan M. Wing. 2012. “Late Onset of Age-Related Difference in Unpaced Tapping with No Age-Related Difference in Phase-Shift Error Detection and Correction.” Psychology and Aging 27 (4): 1152–1163. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0029925.

Turgeon, Martine, Cindy Lustig, and Warren H. Meck. 2016. “Cognitive Aging and Time Perception: Roles of Bayesian Optimization and Degeneracy.” Frontiers in Aging Neuroscience 8: 102. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnagi.2016.00102.

Wittmann, Marc, and Sandra Lehnhoff. 2005. “Age Effects in Perception of Time.” Psychological Reports 97 (3): 921–935. https://doi.org/10.2466/pr0.97.7.921-935.

Comments

7 Responses to “Where Did the Semester Go?”

  1. Gurdit Sra Avatar
    Gurdit Sra

    Hi Isci!
    When Chad mentioned today that this was our last WineSci assignment, it hit me how close we are to the end of the semester. It felt like it went by so fast, and I wanted to know if there was a real biological or psychological reason behind time feeling faster as we age. That question is what this piece is about. Any tips on how to make this better would be appreciated!
    Thank you!
    Gurdit

  2. Natalie Skodyn Avatar
    Natalie Skodyn

    Hi Gurdit,

    Great blog post! I find myself thinking often about how quickly time seems to go by, especially with the busy iSci schedule. I found it fascinating to learn about why it feels like this as we age! A few suggestions for clarity:

    – P1S1: I would split this sentence into two after “felt like a lifetime,” and start the next sentence with “Fast forward, now, to third year,” Additionally, you say “fall semester was over,” I would consider changing this to “and fall semester is almost over in the blink of an eye” as fall semester is still ongoing.
    – P2: I would consider starting this paragraph with a sentence giving context, instead of jumping right into what researchers are experimenting on in the lab.
    – P2S2: Add a comma between “control” and “such as”.
    – I would keep your paragraph headings consistent in colour and size!
    – If word count permits, I would consider elaborating on the role of dopamine in this phenomenon, as you mention it briefly in P4.
    – Your second paragraph heading is a bit confusing in its phrasing. I would consider changing “Except that might not be the clock at all” to something like “Is it truly the clock?”

    Again, great job on your post and I look forward to reading your final version!

    – Natalie 🙂

  3. Kirpa Chandi Avatar
    Kirpa Chandi

    Hi Gurdit,

    Great blog post! I’ve been thinking about this topic a lot lately and your blog post answered some questions I’ve been wondering about. A few suggestions:

    – P2: Consider removing the period and joining the two independent sentences with a comma or semicolon
    – P6S4: Include a comma before “the lectures…”
    – P8S4: Include a comma after “plausible”
    – If word count permits, I think it would be interesting to expand upon the different neural systems you briefly mention at the end of P7
    – Make sure to hyperlink your DOIs!

    Amazing work and happy editing!

    — Kirpa

  4. Ella Nayagar Avatar
    Ella Nayagar

    Hi Gurdit,

    I really like this post! I’m not in third year haha but I have definitely felt like time has gotten faster compared to a few years ago.

    I don’t have much to say – one thing I did notice is that, in the last sentence, “everyday” should be “every day”. Also, at least on my computer screen, one of your subheadings is formatted as an actual heading, but the other two are only bolded.

    Overall, I enjoyed reading!
    Ella

  5. Emma Ramos Avatar
    Emma Ramos

    Hi Gurdit,

    This was a really interesting read, it’s something that I’ve noticed within my own life so far. Thanks for researching about it and sharing it with us! Here are a couple suggestions:

    – In P1S1, I think that it could be broken up into 2 different sentences or use a comma to help break it up more, at the moment it is a long sentence.
    – At the moment, your subheadings are different colours, consider changing them all to the same one for increased continuity in your blog.
    – Make sure that all of your subheadings are also in the same capitalization style for consistency. (Right now “Except that might not be the clock at all” and “The gap that hasn’t been closed” are in sentence case, while “The Brain’s clock” has mixed capitalization)
    – In paragraph 5 when you say “First year needed constant attention..” I think that this could benefit from having a citation with it.
    – Your DOIs are not hyperlinked at the moment, make sure they are before the final draft!

    Happy Editing,

    Emma

  6. Euna Kim Avatar
    Euna Kim

    Hi Gurdit,

    The topic you covered in this blog post was eye-opening and a fun read! It was interesting how you connected the science behind time perception, and going through university.

    Here are some suggestions:

    – One thing I was curious about was how representative the short-interval experiments are of every day time perception. For example, the text explains the perception of several months, while the first experiment explores the intervals of 8 and 21 seconds. Although this is explained later, perhaps discussing the limitation earlier or including further relevant limitations could help readers understand the scope of the evidence!

    – I really liked your concluding reminder to be present everyday. Maybe you can connect this back to the first-year vs the third-year comparison, by being explicit about what being present means. With a meaningful takeaway, this could make your conclusion more connected to the message of the blog.

    Overall, I really enjoyed reading your work, happy editing!

    – Euna

  7. Jua Seok Avatar
    Jua Seok

    Hi Gurdit!

    I really enjoyed reading your blog! I especially liked how you connected the perception of time to the university experience, since it’s something I think many of us can relate to. I also appreciated how you presented multiple scientific explanations rather than treating one theory as the definitive answer. I thought this was a great way to highlight the uncertainty that can exist in scientific research!

    One suggestion I have is to clarify the relationship between dopamine depletion and sustained mental effort in your discussion of the internal clock. Since you also discuss age-related changes in dopamine, I was a little unsure whether these were two separate mechanisms or whether they were directly connected. Briefly distinguishing between them could make your explanation easier to follow.

    Overall, this was a really thought-provoking read, and I especially liked how you ended with a reminder to appreciate the present. Great work!

    Best,
    Jua

Leave a Reply