Alzheimer’s Supports the Patriarchy? A comprehensive look at the differences between female and male bodies and risk of AD

Within the population of USA, Alzheimer’s Disease (AD) disproportionately affects women a lot more, with 2/3 of the overall cases being women (Association 2016). In fact, through numerous studies, it was found that sex, after age, was the most determining factor in Alzheimer’s risk (Subramaniapillai et al. 2021). This is because women are more impacted negatively by factors that increase their risk of Alzheimer’s Disease, including certain hormones, proteins, and neural processing, for reasons that are currently being explored by science but are inconclusive, as most studies focused on male bodies and extrapolated to female bodies, rather than differentiating data by sex. 

A prevalent risk factor in both women and men for AD is the effects of the apolipoprotein E ε4 allele, which plays a significant role in the redistribution of cholesterol and the myelination of neurons in the central nervous system. An increase in the concentration of this protein is linked with normal aging, as well as chronic and inflammatory diseases in the CNS (Torreilles and Touchon 2002). However, the effect of the allele varies between genders. Women in their 60’s who have two alleles of the +APOE-ε4 gene have a higher risk of AD than their male counterparts (Henderson and Authors and Affiliations 1999), for reasons that are currently still being explored through newer studies.  

Another risk factor that is linked with higher rates of Alzheimer’s Disease in women is if a woman’s body has lower levels of hormones that are produced by the ovaries, such as estrogen and progesterone (Fox et al. 2013). Estrogen is especially important as through various studies, it has been shown to inhibit amyloid-plaque β, which is the main driving force behind Alzheimer’s Disease as it interrupts neural pathways in the cerebral cortex and hippocampus regions of our brains (Figure 1). In addition, estrogen helps to drive the removal of this plaque, inhibits neural apoptosis (i.e. cell death), and reduces brain inflammation. However, as women age, lower levels of progesterone and estrogen can be caused by various scenarios, such as if a woman had to have their ovaries surgically removed or if they experience menopause early, which causes the concentration of these hormones to drop significantly and therefore affect how well the brain is able to mitigate AD risk without the help of these ovarian hormones.  

Figure 1: Graph showing the correlation between age and probability of being AD-free. The bolded upper curve shows that women with more months of estrogen exposure have higher chances than the median population of being AD-free as they age. 

These factors are some of the main physiological differences between the female and male bodies which can help to explain why many more cases of Alzheimer’s Disease exist in women than in men. Aside from this, the bias that was present throughout history in scientific study had previously made finding information about Alzheimer’s Disease in women difficult for both patients themselves and caregivers (Association 2016). However, as science becomes more comprehensive, there are numerous opportunities for Alzheimer’s Disease symptoms to improve for all those affected.  

References

Association, Alzheimer s. 2016. “Women and Alzheimer’s | Alzheimer’s Association.” Alzheimer’s Association. https://www.alz.org/alzheimers-dementia/how-alzheimers-impacts-different-groups/women#womenatrisk.

Fox, Molly, Carlo Berzuini, and Leslie A. Knapp. 2013. “Cumulative Estrogen Exposure, Number of Menstrual Cycles, and Alzheimer’s Risk in a Cohort of British Women.” Psychoneuroendocrinology 38 (12): 2973–82. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psyneuen.2013.08.005.

Henderson, P. M. Bretsky J. G. Buckwalter T. E. Seeman C. A. Miller J. Poirier G. D. Schellenberg C. E. Finch V. W., and Authors and Affiliations. 1999. “Evidence for an Interaction Between… : Alzheimer Disease & Associated Disorders.” Ovid. https://www.ovid.com/jnls/alzheimerjournal/pdf/00002093-199910000-00007~evidence-for-an-interaction-between-apolipoprotein-e.

Subramaniapillai, Sivaniya, Anne Almey, M. Natasha Rajah, and Gillian Einstein. 2021. “Sex and Gender Differences in Cognitive and Brain Reserve: Implications for Alzheimer’s Disease in Women.” Frontiers in Neuroendocrinology 60 (100879): 100879. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.yfrne.2020.100879.

Torreilles, François, and Jacques Touchon. 2002. “Pathogenic Theories and Intrathecal Analysis of the Sporadic Form of Alzheimer’s Disease.” Progress in Neurobiology 66 (3): 191–203. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0301-0082(01)00030-2.

Comments

4 Responses to “Alzheimer’s Supports the Patriarchy? A comprehensive look at the differences between female and male bodies and risk of AD”

  1. Kanya Chauhan Avatar
    Kanya Chauhan

    Hi iSci! I wrote about this topic because I was interested to see the physiological and societal differences in how Alzheimer’s Disease affects women vs men. I wanted to relate it back to what we learnt in Intro to Psych about the brain and how it works, as well as bias in scientific research, from a slightly different lens than the one we explored in Life Science, by examining a subsection of human bias towards the male body in medical study and research.

  2. Griffin Suk Avatar
    Griffin Suk

    Hello Kanya,
    Your blog post was a very interesting read, and I really appreciated how you provided a unique perspective on Alzheimer’s! I just have a few comments to help you with your final draft.

    1. I would suggest adding “the” between “of” and “USA” in your opening sentence: “Within the population of USA”. Additionally, I suggest that you start off by saying “United States of America”, and then afterwards putting in brackets (USA). Always make sure to specify what your acronyms mean in scientific writing (even if it can be inferred, it is good practice)!
    2. I suggest removing “In fact” at the start of your second sentence, as it isn’t necessary. Removing it helps to keep your writing succinct.
    3. Make sure that your figure and the text below it are centred!

    Overall, great blog post! I look forward to seeing the final draft.

    Take care,

    Griffin Suk

  3. Kirpa Chandi Avatar
    Kirpa Chandi

    Hi Kanya,

    Amazing blog post! I love neuroscience, so this was a super interesting topic for me and you wrote about it really well! A few suggestions:

    1. In your introduction sentence, it may be a good idea to specify who you’re comparing women to: “…disproportionately affects women a lot more than men…”
    2. Consider splitting the third sentence of your introduction into two, the first about why women are more negatively impacted and the second about why the research is inconclusive.
    3. In P2S2, you write CNS, however you never define the acronym. Make sure you define the acronym after you first write ‘central nervous system’ in P2S1.
    4. This may just be personal preference, but try centering both your figure and figure caption and left aligning your ‘references’ header for a smoother read.
    5. Make sure to hyperlink your DOIs!

    Overall, great work and I can’t wait to read the final product!

    Kirpa

  4. Swetha Subramanian Avatar
    Swetha Subramanian

    Hey Kanya,

    Your topic is so incredibly important in navigating women’s healthcare in this day and age! I really like your use of a graph to show the relationship between age and the probability of being AD-free. Some suggestions I have for you are:

    – In the first sentence, remove the phrase “a lot more” from this phrase: “disproportionately affects women a lot more. ”
    – Sentence two is quite long with no periods in between, so I would suggest cutting it up into separate sentences for more clarity. The same issue occurs in the sentence that explains the lowering of progesterone and estrogen.
    – If you have more space in the conclusion, you could expand a bit more about the gender bias that comes into play when researching women’s health.

    Overall, great job, and I look forward to reading your final draft!

    – Swetha S

Leave a Reply